« PreviousContinue »
These discoveries of Boyle and Leeuwenhoek (as we have already stated) were brought forwards in support of the opinion of those who maintained the infinite divisibility of matter, as it is called. The mathematical proof of the divisibility of matter was likewise forced into the same service. The advocates of the opposite opinion, however, contended that neither the physical experiments nor the mathematical demonstration were conclusive against them; that there was no clear and decisive experiment to shew that a body was composed of divisible parts; and on the contrary, that nature, in the analysis of matter, appeared to stop at a certain degree, and to be fixed and deter. minate. In regard to the mathematical proof, this argument did not apply; the divisibility of a geometrical body not being analogous to the divisibility of a natural and physical body, because the idea of extension involves only that of parts united and co-existing, of which the number is arbitrary, not that of parts actual and determinate, of which the number in any physical body must constitute its essence, and be determinate.
The subjects treated in this first number are
Of the Oak. The nature of it's Production; the different Degrees of Goodness in Oak Timber; and the Causes of that Difference. The Author's Opinion as to the proper Season for felling Timber.'
• Of the Fir.— The different Degrees of Goodness in Fir Timber, how discoverable ; the minute Vessels whichi enter into the Composition of this Tree descriver at large.'
« Of the Weevil or Corn-beetic.-Wherein the common Opinion that this Insect is bred in Corn spontaneously, is shown to be erroneous ; the true Nature of its Generation explained ; with the Means to preserve Corn from its Infection.”
• Of the Maggot or Caterpillar intesting Corn in Granaries; the Nature of its Generation explained, and the Means to prevent its Increase pointed out.'
• Of the Spider. The following observations were made on those kinds of Spiders which are found in gardens, where they fix their webs to vines, herbs, and shumnbs:'
Of the Silk Worm.'
On the nature of the scales of Fishes, and how the age of those Animals may be determined by, observation of the scales ; The Author's reasonings and opinion respecting the Longevity of this part of the Animal Creation.
The Author's réfutation of the doctrine of equivocal or spon. taneous generation in the instance of the Sea Musole, with a particular description of that species of Fish,'
of the Muscle which is found in fresh water; a particular description of its internal formation, and of tire manner in which its young are produced.'
We have not heard that any additional numbers of this work have appeared :- When they reach us, we shall report them to the public.
Art. XI.' Further Observations on the Variola Vaccina, or Cow.pox.
By Edward Jenner, M.D. F. R. S. F. L. S. &c. 4to. 256d.
ist, Facts' which point out the fallacious sources whence a disease imitative of (resembling) the true Variola Vaccine might arise ; with the view of preventing those who may inoculate, from producing a spurious disease. 2dly, They relate to
subduing the inoculated pustule, as soon as it has sufficiently produced its influence on the constitution.
The necessity of a farther statement of facts, relating to the Ist head, appears from the accounts given of persons taking the small-pox, who had previously undergone the Var. Vac.
On these cases,' says the author, I shall for the present suspend any particular
remarks, but hope that the general observations I have to offer in the sequel will prove of sufficient weight to render the idea of their ever having had existence, but as cases of spurious cow-pox, extremely doubtful.'
Dr. J. next enumerates the sources of a spurious cow-pox.
' ist; That arising from pustules on the nipples or udder of the cow; which pustules contain no specific virus.
2dly, From matter (although originally possessing the specific virus) which has suffered a decomposition, either from putrefaction or from any other cause less obvious to the senses.
3dly, Froin matter taken from an ulcer in an advanced stage, which ulcer arose from a true cow-pox.
4thly, From matter produced on the human skin from contat with some peculiar morbid matter generated by a horse.'
The terms of the 2d proposition are hypothetical, and the distinction between the 2d and 3d is suficiently obscure : but the reader may expect the elucidation in the commentary on them. :
Concerning the first source of disease above-mentioned, Dr. J. tells us that the udders and nipples are subject to a variety of eruptions, and that many of them are capable of giving a disease to the human body different from the true cow-pox : but, after having raised these doubts, and recommended a suspension of all opinion as to what is and what is not the real Cow-pox, we get no satisfactory information from the author. Indeed, according to our apprehension, tlze distinctions pointer su out are vague; and perhaps merely hypothetical. A case in point is thus stated :
-Sarah Merlin milked a cow whose nip. ples were affected with large white blisters: the girl's hands became affected in like manner with blisters, and inflammas tion, but no constitutional indisposition followed ; this disF ( 2
order being considered as the variola vascina, the patient was thought to be secure from the small-pox: but she afterwards took this disease, and had a full byrthen. Now,' says the author, 'had any one, conversant with the habits of this disease, heard this history, they (he) would have had no hesitation in pronouncing it a case of spurious cow-pox; considering its deviation in the numerous blisters which appeared on the girl's hand; their termination without ulceration, its not proving more generally contagious at the farm, either among the cattle or those employed in milking : and considering also that the patient felt no general indisposition, although there was so great a number of vesicles.' We will venture to afirm, from tlie accounts of the cow-pox published in the current year, that these observations do not distinguish that complaint from other similar diseases.
With respect to the 2d source of diseases resembling the cow-pox :- instances are related of persons having, by inocu. Iation with variolous matter, an infiammation, pustules, pains in the axille, and fever at the usual time, yet they afterward took the small-pox; and these failures were imputed to the state of the variolous matter used in the inoculation. After this, ought we,' says the Doctor, to be in the smallest degree surprized to find, among a great number of individuals, whe by living in dairies have been casually exposed to the cow-pos virus, when in a state analogous to that of the small-pos above described, some who may have had the disease so irperfectiy as not to render them secure from variolous attacks :' Thus, then, from analogy only, it is concluded that spuricus cases of cow-pox occur from the altered state of the real mare ter of this disease.
Concerning the 3d source of diseases liable to be cor founded with the var. val., not a single evidence from practice is adduced: but the author shall speak for himself:
6. I shall observe that, when this pustule has degenerated into ulcer, (to which state it is often disposed to pass unless time checked,) I suspect that matter possessing very different properties may sooner or later be produceu; and although it may have passed
hat stage wherein the specific properties of the matter secrcicd 22 no longer present in it, yet, when applied to a sore (as in the cascal way) it might dispose that sore to ulcerate, and from its irritating the system would probably become afiected; and thus, by assuming some of its strongest characters, it would imitate the genuine cca pox.'
We next come to the 4th origin of diseases; and here it is maintained that the cow-pox is derived from the horse. * do not think it necessary to state the reasons for this opinios
as given by the author, because they amount to no more than
presumptive evidence ; and even this has been refuted by Se other evidence of the same kind, or in part by direct contrary * proof from inoculation with the matter of grease,-~from the
absence of the cow-pox where the grease prevails, -and from the prevalence of it where no such disease as the grease was present. As, in our account of Dr. Jenner's former work, we
expressed our disapprobation of the conclusion that grease He was the origin of the cow-pox, and he still persists in the opi
nion, but without any additional evidence, we must now take the liberty of saying, that the credit of neither the present nor the former work would have been lessened by the omission of the unsound reasoning on this topic.
By way of preparation for the practice with escharctics and caustics, the following observations are delivered :
• From the very slight indisposition which ensucs in cases of inoculation, where the pustule after affecting the constitution quickly runs into a scab spontaneously, or is artificially suppressed by some proper application, I am induced to believe that the violence of the symptoms may be ascribed to the inflammation and irritation of the ulcers, and that the constitutional symptoms which appear durmg the presence of the sore while it assumes the character of a pustule only are felt but in a very trifling degree. This mild affection of the system Irappens when the disease makes but a slight local impression
on those who have been accidentally infected by cows; and, as far as s I have seen, it has uniformly happened among those who have lea
inoculated, when a pustule only, and no great degree of infamation, or any ulceration, has taken place from the inoculation.'
Dr. Jenner next relates two instances of the vario's vaccine, in which, on the 14th day, an inflammatory appearance taking płace around the inoculated part, ointment was applied, con
sisting of unguentum hydrargyri nitrati, and plaister of yng. by5 drargyri fort., and in two or three days the virus seemed to be
subdued. As, however, the practice with these applications does not appear to be necessary, we shall suspend our opinion, till we have heard the reports which may be expected from others who have very extensively practised the vaccine inoculation. At the close of the pamphlet, are inserted some communications to shew that the cow-pox is a perfectly safe disease, even to infants: one only twenty hours old' having gone through it without apparent illness; yet it was found effectually to resist the action of variolous matter with which it was subsequently inoculated.'
Although the present work does not contain matter of such isterest, and which gives such satisfaction, as many parts of Dr. Jenner's former publicarion afforded, we shall always be
happy to peruse his communications on one of the most important subjects, perhaps, ever brought under medical discus. sion; and we shall ever gratefully regard Dr, Jenner as the original writer..
i92108 10 Sen In
If Arno XII. Reports of a Series of Inoculations for the Variae Vaccine, Yor Cowbox; with Remarks and Observations on this Disease, cor
sidered as a substitute for the Small.pox. By William Woodville, M.D. Physician to the Small-pox and Inoculation Hospitals
. 20180 pp. 155. 35. 6d. sēwed. Phillips arid Son. W1799. T *118 publications which have hitherto appeared on this
subjuct contain satisfactory'evidence with respect to certain facts, from which some important advantages in medical practice are calculable; provided, however, that certain other facts, at present unestablished, do not prove, 'on farther
research, to counterbalance those advantages, or that new facts do not arise which evince detriment. Yet, while we are aware of and duly report such unfavorable results from the prosecution of the inquiry, it is no more than Bare justice to allow that the investigation may afford conclusions which exhibit additional advantages in practice. Much has been writica 1. on thiş subject, but it has principally consisted of unauthenti
cared reports and à priori unsound reasoning. Well attested : and copious evidence was yet wanting, to enable the public to s, estimate the value of the new inoculation. The present work
bears directly on this deficient point, viz. that of evidence; and the judgment, the industry, and the opportunities of the : author, secured us from being disappointed in our expectations of much satisfaction from these reports.
Dr. Woodville says, “I conceived it to be a duty that I owed to the public, in my official situation at the Inoculation Hospital, to embrace the first opportụnity of carrying the plan
into execution,' Not being able to procure vaccine inatter, he i proceeded to try whether the disease could be actually excited
by inoculating the nipples of cows with matter of grease; in conformity to the opinion that the cow.pox originated in the grease, . The numerous experiments made by the author, low
ever, as well as by Professor Coleman, (of the Veterinary Col.. lege,) in order to produce the disease in cows by the inoculation
of the grease maiter, and other equine morbit secreted fluids, proved unsuccessful. In a note, the curious fact is stated, tha, although the variola vaccina could not be produced in the cow's teats by the inoculation either of variolous matter, or of vaccine matter from the cow, Mr. Coleman did succeert in exciting the discase in this animal by inoculation of cut-pox inatter from