| Sir Graves Chamney Haughton - Philosophy - 1839 - 298 pages
...been first conceived. When, however, this argument is duly considered, it will, perhaps, be admitted, that it exhibits a more natural mode of reasoning...conclusion is as convincing as that of the syllogism." p. 146. (*) Or, Aggregation. § 176. Mind, in common with all substance (for they hold it to be such)... | |
| Graves Champney Haughton - Reasoning - 1839 - 292 pages
...been first conceived. When, however, this argument is duly considered, it will, perhaps, be admitted, that it exhibits a more natural mode of reasoning...conclusion is as convincing as that of the syllogism." p. 146. (83) Or, Aggregation. § 176. Mind, in common with all substance (for they hold it to be such)... | |
| Annambhaṭṭa - Nyaya - 1851 - 554 pages
...commended, at the expense of the Aristotelian syllogism, on the allegation (see a quotation in Sir GC Haughton's Prodromus, p. 215,) " that it exhibits...based Simply on a misconception of the syllogism thus disr garaged. On the 6th er hand, when it is censured ias " a rude form of the syllogism," the censure... | |
| Annambhaṭṭa - Nyaya - 1918 - 476 pages
...and clumsy form of syllogism, while others prefer it to the Aristotelian syllogism as exhibiting " a more natural mode of reasoning than is compatible with the compressed limits of the syllogism."* Both the praise and the blame however are only partially true. The five-membered Ny&ya reflects no... | |
| Jonardon Ganeri - Philosophy - 2001 - 238 pages
...fivestep format is understood as a stylised representation of the stages in a rhetorical debate, then it exhibits "a more natural mode of reasoning than...compatible with the compressed limits of the syllogism" (vans Kennedy, 1839). The presence of five, rather than three, steps, is natural, they suggest, when... | |
| |