Page images
PDF
EPUB

The Nation: the Foundations of Civil Order and
Political Life in the United States. By E. Mul-
ford. (New York, Hurd & Houghton.)
As it was the fashion, some time ago, to preach
the divine right of kings, so we have here a dis-
course on the divine right of nations. Mr. Mul-
ford, who sometimes writes so clearly that we
regret, at other times, to find his ideas full of
confusion, has a theory that nations, especially
the one to which he belongs, do not originate in
the social contract, but are of divine foundation.
To this thesis and its development he dedicates
a considerable volume, and at times, as we have
said, he reasons well. The tendency of the whole
work is, however, too vague and speculative to
take any hold upon the mind.

We have on our table: The Student's Manual of Oriental History, by F. Lenormant and E. Chevallier, Vol. II. (Asher),- The Scottish Poor Laws, by Scotus (Edmonston & Douglas),- Land and Houses, by J. Parnell (E. Wilson), -The Royal Guide to London Charities, by H. Fry (Hardwicke), The Parish Leech, by a Parish Doctor" (Nicholls),-Thoughts and Sketches in Verse, by C. P. J. (Longmans), and On Christian Care of the Dying and the Dead, by a Clergyman of the Church of England (Hayes). Among new editions we have A Greek Delectus, by the Rev. R. Valpy, edited by J. T. White, D.D. (Longmans), and An Atlas of Scripture Geography, with Index, by W. M'Lead (Longmans). Also the following pamphlets Building Societies and Borrowers, by C. D. A. Friedlein (Siegle),--The Disposal of Town Sewage, by R. W. P. Birch (Spon),-Speech on the Contagious Diseases Acts, by Jacob_Bright, Esq., M.P. (Manchester, Ireland & Co.),-Lady Wilmerding of Maison Rouge, by D. Craig, M.A. (Macintosh),-Salome (Macintosh),-The Declaration of War, a Sermon by the Rev. S. Brooke (Macmillan),-Biology versus Theology, by Julian, No. 6 (Lewes, Bacon),-and Widows in their Affliction (Macintosh).

LIST OF NEW BOOKS.
Philosophy.

Doubleday's Matter for Materialists, 8vo. €/ cl.

Poetry.

Adams's (W.) Glena of the Creek, and other Poems, sq. 18mo. 2/
Curwen's Echoes from the French Poets, 12mo. 5 cl.
Legge's Wayside Sketches, in Prose and Verse, cr. 8vo. 4 6 cl.
Thoughts and Sketches in Verse, by C. P. J., cr. 8vo. 3/6 cl.

History.

Chesney and Reeve's Military Resources of Prussia & France, 7/6
Cusack's Life of St. Patrick, Apostle of Ireland, 4to. 30 cl.
Herbert's (Lord E.) History of England under Henry VIII., 5/
Hodgson's Life, Times and Opinions of Turgot, er. 8vo. 2/ swd.
Lacroix's Mœurs, Usages et Costumes au Moyen-âge, 4to. 32 cl.
Some Revelations in Irish History, ed. by Saxe Bannister, 7/6
Tayler's W. Popes of Rome, from the Earliest Times, 12mo. 3/
Wheater's Record of the Services of the 51st Regiment, 8vo. 10.6
Geography.

Knapsack Guide to Norway, new edit. 12mo. 6/ limp roan.
M'Queen's Bird's-Eye View of the Seat of War, col. sheet, 3/
Ravenstein's Map of the Seat of War, sheet, 1/
Stanford's Rhine Frontier Map, 2, 6 sheet, 5 mounted.
Stannard's Perspective Map of the Seat of War, sheet, 2/

Philology.

Eve and De Baudiss's Wellington College French Primer, 3/
Mason's English Grammar, new edit. 12mo. 3 cl.
Sylvester's Laws of Verse, &c., cr. Svo. 4/0 cl.

Science.

Burgh's Link-Motion and Expansion-Gear Considered, 4to. 42/
Fennell's Book of the Roach, 12mo. 26 cl.

Riddell's New Elements of Hand-Railing, 4to. 21/ cl.
Robinson's (W.) The Wild Garden, cr. 8vo. 6/ cl.

Waring's Earth Closets and Earth Sewage, 8vo. 3/ swd.

General Literature.

Grosart the entire MSS. of Lord Brooke's Poetry,
&c. (6 vols. folio). They were sold at the Bright
sale, as Mr. Grosart mentions in the Prefatory
Note to the first volume of Lord Brooke's works,
and have ever since been lost sight of. The
Earl has also most courteously and generously pro-
mised an early and thorough examination of the
family papers at Warwick Castle, with an assur-
to Mr. Grosart's literary materials. Haunted, so to
ance of the gratification it will give him to add
say, by the conviction that there are Shakspeare
MSS. among the Warwick and Brooke family
papers, Mr. Grosart cherishes the "Pleasures of
Hope" concerning the intended search among
them. May they not prove "Pleasures of Imagina-
tion"! The results, if any, will at once be made
known, and meantime, Mr. Grosart states that a
collation thus far of the above-mentioned MSS.
has already yielded numerous and important
readings all through, while not a few make clear
places hitherto hopelessly obscure and corrupt.
The whole collation will be exhibited in an Ap-
pendix to Vol. IV. (now at press along with Vol.
III.); and the following fac-similes from the MSS.
will be given: Part of the pieces entitled 'Of
Monarchie,' (in careful transcript, showing Lord
Brooke's corrections,) and 'Of Religion,' wholly in
the author's autograph,-his signature, and hand-
writing in old age. Mr. Grosart desires to state,
in answer to the numerous letters of inquiry that
daily reach him, that he cannot now supply even
a single complete set (in large paper) of the "Fuller
Worthies' Library," and only a very few sets in
Worthies' Library," and only a very few sets in
small paper. To his Fuller and Washbourne, Sir
John Davies, Giles Fletcher, Phineas Fletcher, Joseph
Fletcher, Sir John Beaumont, Lord Brooke, and
Miscellanies (13 volumes in all, to this date), Mr.
Grosart hopes to add Lord Brooke, Vols. III. and
IV., in November (along with the remaining Mis-
cellanies of Vol. I.): and, in 1871-2, the complete
works in verse and prose of Henry Vaughan, the
Silurist (4 vols.); Richard Crashaw, with nearly a
half more hitherto unpublished (2 vols.) complete
poems, with considerable additions of Dr. John
Donne (2 vols.), and Vol. II. of Miscellanies; and
so in successive years kindred Worthies.

--

SHAKSPEARE.

British Museum, August 9, 1870.

EVEN the bare mention of the name of Shakspeare is a thing that so seldom occurs in the publications of our great civil period that I have thought the following may prove interesting to your readers. It is an extract from one of the Mercuries of the year 1644, which, besides exhibiting the names of Shakspeare and some of our other early dramatists, may serve also as a specimen of the journalistic amenities of the time in which it appeared :

Numb. 20.

'Mercurius Britannicus: communicating the affaires of great Britaine: For the better Information of the People. From Thursday the 4. of January to Thursday 11. of January 1644.'-— Aulicus keeps to the old way of devotion, and that is the offering up the incense of so many lies and intelligence every Sunday morning: one would thinke that the Judgements which have been sent from heaven against the prophanation of that day, recorded by our protomartyr, Master Burton, should be able to deterre a Diurnall maker, a paper

Brown (Peter, Poet and Peripatetic, Revelations of, 12mo. 2/6 intelligencer, a penny worthe of newes, but the

Churchman's (The Shilling Magazine, Vol. 7, 8vo. 7/6 cl.
Craik's Esther Hill's Secret, 3 vols. cr. 8vo. 31 6 cl.
Hugo's Victor Toilers of the Sea, cheap edit. 12mo. 2 bds.
Matthews's Bristol Directory, remodelled by Wright, 1870, 5/
Pare's Co-operative Agriculture, cr. 8vo. 5/ el.
Sketchley's (A.) Out for a Holiday with Cook's Excursion, 1/

FULKE (GREVILLE) LORD BROOKE.

WE are glad to learn from the Rev. Alexander B. Grosart (of Blackburn), the editor of the "Fuller Worthies' Library," of which the complete works of Fulke (Greville) Lord Brooke, form Vols. XI. to XIV., that in spontaneous response to the appeal seconded by the Athenæum (No. 2231), the present Earl of Warwick and Brooke has forwarded to Mr.

for the brain, the restoratives for the wit, the bathing for the wine muses, but none of these are now able either to warme him into a quibble, or to inflame him into a sparkle of invention, and all this because he hath prophaned the Sabbath by his pen. G. B.

creature hath writ himselfe into a reprobate sense,
and you may see how it thrives with him, for his
braines have been wonderfully blasted of late, and
plannet-strucke, and he is not now able to provoke
the meanest Christian to laughter, but lies in a
paire of foule sheets, a wofull spectacle and object
of dullnesse and tribulation, not to be recovered
by the Protestant or Catholique liquour, either
ale or strong beer, or Sack or Claret, or Hippocras,
or Muscadine, or Rosas plis, which has been reputed
formerly by his Grandfather Ben Johnson and his
uncle Shakespeare, and his Cowzen Germains,
Fletcher, and Beamont, and nose-lesse Davenant,
and Frier Sherley the Poets, the onely blossoms

THE OFFICIAL RECORD OF THE EXPEDITION TO
ABYSSINIA.

WILL you allow me, as an officer of the Abyssinian force, to reply to Aba Busbus.

Having read the Official Record' and all the other works describing the campaign, except Mr. Markham's book, I am, perhaps, able to give an opinion on some of the points noted by Aba Busbus, who evidently never had anything to do with the equipment of a force for a campaign, or he would hardly have condemned the clear and concise account of the arrangements preparatory to the Abyssinian War, so graphically given in the Official Record.'"

[ocr errors]

The "mass of reports and tabular statements" and the pages of editorial narrative here and there" may demonstrate "the uselessness of the compilation" to Aba Busbus, but they are simply invaluable to those who may have at any time to organize an expedition like that lately sent to Abyssinia.

Aba Busbus was probably unaware when he criticized the descriptions of military operations given in the 'Official Record,' that these descriptions had been carefully scrutinized and approved by Lord Napier of Magdala before insertion in the

Official Record'; and further, that these descriptions coincide with every published history of the campaign except, I believe, with that given in Mr. Markham's book, which can scarcely be considered as a work to be relied on, in military matters at all events.

The remarks of Aba Busbus on the geography of Abyssinia, and on the spelling and pronunciation of names, I leave to others to reply to. There is no doubt that great opportunities were lost in obtaining correct geographical information in Abyssinia, and therefore the compilers of the 'Official Record' were perhaps right in only giving a few lines in their valuable work to the proceedings of the geographer.

One of the clerks of the India Office accompanied the force, I believe, to take the altitudes of noted places; but I am not aware if he ever made any CABIN BOY. official report of his proceedings.

PARIS AND THE WAR.

Paris, August 10, 1870. THE war has driven almost everything but that which relates to itself out of the heads of the Parisians. Literature and Art are always the first to suffer from any commotion in society; the newspapers are the only things read, and they are almost scrambled for; the unfortunate edict which prevented the journalists from satisfying the natural desire for information being relaxed now that every word that comes from the front blanches the cheek of the strongest, and falls like a pall upon the city. Strange fatality of Governments, that forget, though they never learn!

Before the news of the reverses came from the Rhine and the Lauter, the theatres and the streets resounded almost day and night with the 'Marseillaise,' the 'Chant des Girondins,' and the Rhin Allemand.' Perhaps some of our readers do not know what this last song is. It is the reply of De Musset to Becker's famous patriotic song, the first line having been improvised by the spirituelle Madame de Girardin

[ocr errors][merged small]

Nous l'avons eu, votre Rhin allemand,
Que faisaient vos vertus germaines,
Quand notre César tout-puissant

De son ombre couvrait vos plaines?
Où donc est-il tombé ce dernier ossement?
Nous l'avons eu, votre Rhin allemand,
Si vous oubliez votre histoire,
Vos jeunes filles, sûrement,

Ont mieux gardé notre mémoire:
Elles nous ont versé votre petit vin blanc.
S'il est à vous, votre Rhin allemand,

Lavez-y donc votre livrée;

Mais parlez-en moins fièrement,
Combien, au jour de la curée,

Étiez-vous de corbeaux contre l'aigle expirant?
Qu'il coule en paix, votre Rhin allemand!
Que vos cathédrales gothiques

S'y reflètent modestement !

Mais craignez que vos airs bachiques

Ne réveillent les morts de leur repos sanglant. The only chanson de circonstance which has achieved any success in Paris is the 'Je suis Chauvin,' by Saint-Germain, of the Vaudeville, who sang it at a meeting of the Caveau before the news of disaster came :

LE CHANSON D'AUJOURD'HUI

[blocks in formation]

M. de Clésien sent us, in the Indépendance Bretonne, a song, of which the following are the best stanzas:

Voici les Bretons, aujourd'hui Français,
Avançant toujours, ne cédant jamais! (bis)

Ils n'ont plus leur casque et le fier cimier,
Mais ils ont leur front dur comme l'acier.
En avant, Bretons, en avant toujours!
Notre chant guerrier vaut mille tambours !
Combattant joyeux, à pied, à cheval,
Lance ou chassepot, ça nous est égal!
Des pleurs ont coulé sur nos ceinturons,
Dans le sang prussien nous les laverons.
Femmes, mères, sœurs, soyez à genoux
Quand nous combattrons pour vous et pour nous.
L'amour du pays est un bel amour,

Et nous reverrons nos clochers à jour! When the false news of victory arrived, the populace was half frantic with joy; in the midst of the excitement, the tenor Capoul was recognized on the Place de la Bourse, and the mob insisted on his singing the 'Marseillaise,' which he did from the top of an omnibus (arrested for the purpose), with a terrific chorus of thousands of voices. A like scene occurred on the Boulevard, where Madame Sass roused the feelings of her rough-and-ready audience to a pitch of excitement which, under different circumstances, might have overturned a throne.

The revulsion of feeling, the fearful explosion of rage which occurred when the news was found to be totally unfounded, was dangerous. The Bourse got credit at once for its fabrication, and the berceau, or railed ring within which the agents de change transact business, was torn up from the floor and demolished. Difficulties occurred in

several quarters, and the anxiety of the Government was intense-a single spark thrown by accident or otherwise in that heated mass and all would have been in a blaze. The excitement has to a certain extent passed away, but the feverish thirst for news of a happy turn of fortune in the field is terrible, and we feel as if we were sitting on a mine with sparks all around us. The commencement of the arming of the fortifications of Paris, the announcement that 33,000 men will complete the defences in a week, the summoning

of every man under thirty years of age to join the garde mobile, and of all under forty-five to serve in the garde nationale, with Paris declared in a state of siege, and the head-quarters of the army removed from Nancy to Châlons-sur-Marne (half-way on the road to Paris), these facts have produced an impression on all classes of the population which is dreadful to regard and impossible to escape from.

When the defeats were first made known the despair of the people was indescribable, and the tone of the despatches from the frontier, of the ministerial mandates, and of the press, was not of a nature to rouse a spirit fitting the occasion. This was soon seen, and has to a great extent been corrected; and a writer in one of the Parisian papers had the happy idea of invoking the shade of the chansonnier of chansonniers-every line of which rings like a trumpet, and which no one but Béranger could have penned. The following stanzas might have been written to-day-had there been a second Béranger:

[merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small][ocr errors][merged small][merged small][merged small][merged small]

De la France !

Gai, gai, serrons nos rangs,

En avant, Gaulois et Francs!

Yes, says the journalist, M. Émile Blayet, "Serrons nos rangs! et que cette voix d'outretombe nous indique ce qu'il reste à faire."

All the theatres have given performances in aid of the fund for the wounded. At the Français a duologue, entitled 'Pour les Blessés,' written for the occasion by M. Eugène Manuel, was played by M. Coquelin and Malle. Favart; the former representing a wounded soldier, the latter his young nurse. The following are the most noticeable passages.

Le Blessé opens his eyes, sees near him the sweet devoted face of the young infirmière, and tells how he was wounded:

Nous avions combattu tout le jour sans relâche.
Dans nos rangs, pas un homme ébranlé, pas un lâche !
Et, quand on attaquait, nous entonnions ce chant
Qui vous fait triompher déjà, rien qu'en marchant.
A ce moment, chaque âme est ferme et bien munie:
Sous le regard de Dieu, seule, elle communie;
A ceux qu'on aime on donne un dernier souvenir.
Dieu seul dirait comment bat le coeur d'une armée
Qui court en frémissant à travers la fumée.
Le sacrifice est fait et la mort peut venir.
On ne se pose plus de problème inutile:
Pourquoi l'on meurt, pourquoi l'on tue ou l'on mutile,
Pourquoi ce but vivant qu'on vise à l'horizon.
Chacun boit d'un seul trait la coupe où l'on s'enivre;
On ne demande plus s'il faut mourir ou vivre:
Une force inconnue emporte la raison !

LA JEUNE FEMME.

Votre voix est trop animée.
J'ai peur d'avoir tant écouté.
Est-elle donc si bien fermée,
Hélas! la blessure enflammée
Qui saignait à votre côté ?..
LE BLESSÉ.

La plaine n'était plus qu'une paille hachée
Où le sang abreuvait la terre desséchée.
J'avais vu près de moi rouler de chers amis;
Mais j'avançais toujours: je me l'étais promis.
Nous franchissions vergers, ruisseaux, ravins, collines,
Hameaux, où le canon n'a laissé que ruines;

J'avais chaud, j'avais soif, et j'étais affamé.
Sur mon cœur j'avais mis un portrait bien-aimé,
Ma mère,
-un talisman sacré pour qui s'expose,
Quand d'un vieux bâtiment, dont la porte était close,
Un poste d'habits verts fit feu subitement;
Et, sans pousser un cri, je tombai lourdement.
(Elle lui prend la main.)

J'entendais le clairon, couché contre une haie:
Et tandis qu'à l'attaque on faisait rude accueil,
Je sentais s'écouler tout le sang de ma plaie.
Alors de mes vingt ans je pris tout bas le deuil,
Et je m'évanouis dans un rêve d'orgueil...

*

*

[ocr errors]

Other theatres have had their pièces de circonstance, or verses, but they are generally unworthy of notice from a literary point of view.

The war the other day furnished a good many spectators with the rare exhibition of a million of money. A foreign banker presented a draft for one million of francs and received the whole of it in five-franc pieces. The mass half filled the yard of the Banque de France, and was watched over by the Gardes de Paris while the banker got it conveyed away in furniture vans. The legal weight of a silver five-franc piece is 25 grammes, and a ton contains exactly one million grammes, so that the banker had just 25 tons of silver to carry away.

MR. J. P. COLLIER AND CHAUCER'S 'TESTAMENT OF LOVE.'

*

Y.

August 2, 1870.

SINCE my controversy with Mr. J. P. Collier in your columns about a year ago, as to whether he was the first person, as he claimed to be, who had stated publicly that the 'Testament of Love' was not Chaucer's, and whether his statement was of any value, his 'Bibliographical Catalogue,' 1865, has come into my hands; and at page 424 of vol. ii. is the following important contradictory passage on the question at issue, although Mr. Collier quoted in your columns a MS. entry of his, dated Oct. 20, 1855, saying that Chaucer did not write the Testament.' +

"He [Taylor the Water-Poet] summarily settles the disputed question of the place of Chaucer's birth, observing of Woodstock, 'The towne is a pretty market-towne, chiefly famous for the breeding of the famous Jeffrey Chaucer, the most ancient Archpoet of England.' Leland asserts that Chaucer was born in Oxfordshire or Berkshire; but how are we to reconcile this statement with that of the Poet himself, who, in his 'Testament of Love,' tells us that he was 'a Londoner'? This agrees with Stow, Speght's Chaucer, 1598, sign b. ii., who says that Chaucer's father, Richard, was a vintner in St. Mary Aldermary. We do not, of course, take Taylor to be any authority on the point."

Is Mr. Collier one, I ask, on the authenticity of the 'Testament of Love'? In 1855, he says, he wrote that it was not Chaucer's; in 1865, as against Taylor and Leland, he printed that it was Chaucer's; as against Mr. Bradshaw's proof to me in 1863-5, that Chaucer did not write the book, Mr. Collier produces a private entry in October, 1865, and a printed one in August, 1867, that the poet did not write it either, and that for many years he (Mr. Collier) had entertained that opinion. Black is white, and black is black: Mr. Collier can prove either assertion. F. J. FURNIVALL.

MONUMENTS OF THE DISCOVERIES OF THE
PORTUGUESE IN AFRICA.

A FEW notes from a learned paper upon this subject, read before the Royal Academy of Sciences, at Lisbon, on the 11th of March, 1869, by an officer of the Portuguese navy, Senhor Castilho, will perhaps be acceptable to many readers interested in the history of African discovery, to whom the original paper may not be readily accessible.

* I am ready to declare my belief that [Mr. Collier's] assertion is not worth a straw to Chaucer students, "F. J. F." in Athenæum, No. 2166, May 1, 1869, p. 607, col. 1.

+ If called upon to show how long this notion had possessed my mind, I might go back, not, like Mr. Furnivall, to 1863, but to 1855, when I first obtained Godfray's impression of Chaucer's works, printed in 1532, where the 'Testament of Love' originally appeared. I then read it with all attention; and I may here, perhaps, be allowed to quote my own memorandum upon the title-page, made as I proceeded with the perusal. It runs precisely thus: "It may be remarked how late in the sentence Chaucer often places the verb in this prose work: see folio cccxxx, &c. Query, Was it by Chaucer? Certainly not, Oct. 20, 1855." Mr. J. P. Collier in the Athenæum, No. 2167, May 8, 1869, p. 638, col. 3.

[ocr errors]

It was a custom of the early Portuguese navigators, Senhor Castilho tells us, to record the discovery of new territories by the erection thereon of simple crosses of wood, in some instances accompanied by a representation of the arms of Portugal, and the date of discovery, rudely graven upon some neighbouring tree. But they rarely determined the geographical positions of the new localities; and as these frail memorials soon disappeared, it was thought desirable to substitute for them some more permanent erections to establish the claim to priority of discovery, and to preclude the possibility of international disputes. Hence, in the reign of Dom John II. it became a usual practice to provide discovery ships with materials for the erection of monuments of marble or dressed stone in suitable situations, each padrão, or memorial column, being surmounted by a cross, as a symbol of the protection which was ever invoked for our conquests, and in the hope that communication might be thereby opened up with Prester John, who was reported to hold the Christian faith." It must be observed that these memorials have been generally described by English and French geographers as crosses, a term which has led to some misconception. The monuments described by Senhor Castilho as set up on the shores of the Atlantic and Indian Oceans are twelve in number. Of these, three erected by Diogo Cam, and three by Bartholemew Diaz, are referable to the reign of Dom John II., and the remaining six, planted by Vasco da Gama, to the reign of Dom Manuel. The learned and painstaking João de Barrós, who has been styled the Portuguese Livy, describes the memorials of Diogo Cam as follows:-They were double the height of a man, and surmounted by a cross of dressed stone. They bore upon one side the royal arms, and upon the opposite an inscription recording, in Portuguese and Latin, the discovery of the territory, "by order of the king," the date thereof, and the name of the commander by whom the column was erected. (J. de Barrós, "Da Asia.") Some writers assert that a third inscription, in Arabic, was added. Senhor Castilho observes, that the columns, which are still in existence, or were a few years back, agree satisfactorily with De Barrós' description. He gives the annexed details of the twelve columns above referred to, arranged in chronological order.

marino,' 1866,) this monument was composed of a cylindrical column, without pediment, 2 m. 64 in height, and Om. 2 to Om. 3 in diameter, terminating in a parallelopiped Om. 44 in height, and of Om. 50 side, formed of a single block-the whole of white veined marble. The armorial bearings were the same as in the preceding examples. The inscription was illegible. M. Rudzky found, surmounting the column, a rudely-fashioned cross of iron, much rusted, upon one of the arms of which, in copper letters soldered to the iron plate, was MERCURE, 27 Jer, 1848." This addition was removed forthwith, and on the subsequent visit of M. Lopez the cross itself had disappeared, but the column remained.

1. A column dedicated to S. Jorge, situated on what is now marked upon English charts as Turtle Point, on south side of mouth of Congo River. This monument had suffered much from the ravages of time, and possibly from the ill-usage of early Dutch settlers, and by order of the Portuguese Government, it was replaced by a new column, bearing a suitable inscription, on 13th September, 1859. Later official reports state that the new memorial was carried away by a flood in 1864. The date of the original was probably 1484, although most writers make it 1485.

[ocr errors]

The columns erected by Bartholemew Diaz, Senhor Castilho assumes to have differed little, if at all, from those of his contemporary Diogo Cam. They were:

name.

1. A column dedicated to S. Jago, erected at the end of the year 1486, or at the beginning of 1487, upon a spot designated "Serra Parda" (the brown hills). Much discussion has been caused by this M. Castilho refers the site to Point Bartholemew Diaz, in long. 15° 2′ or 16′ E., Greenwich, and lat. 26° 35′ S. on the south side of the bay containing the Shark, Seal, and Penguin Islands. This point, he says, has two small dark-coloured hillocks, which present the appearance of an island at a short distance. In confirmation of his supposition, he adds, that Captains Sir Home Popham and Thompson, of the British navy, when examining this coast in 1786, found remains upon this spot; and in 1845, when M. Saisset undertook to restore the monuments, he found stones, with traces of inscriptions upon them, on the hummocks aforesaid. These remains were, however, too fragmentary to allow him to carry his project into effect.

2. A column upon Cape St. Maria, now Cape St. Augustine, long. 12° 29′ 24" E., Greenwich, lat. 13° 27′ 15′′ S.; date 1485. Mr. Major (Life of Prince Henry,' pp. 331 and 346), to whose scrupulous exactitude M. Castilho pays the highest tribute, places the site on Cape Negro, lat. 15° 50′ 0′′ S. This is evidently an error. Senhor Castilho observes that no doubt can exist upon the subject, inasmuch as the column was seen by him on Cape St. Augustine (at the distance of a mile), in 1851, and was measured by one of his brother officers, M. Lopez, in 1854. It proved to be 2 m. in total height. It was cylindrical to a height of 1m. 7 from the ground, the remaining portion being worked to a four-sided prism of Om. 3 side. On one face were the arms of Portugal, and on the others some nearly illegible Gothic characters. Upon the W. face was "XXXI." in Roman letters; also "Serra do Pilar, 10.5.54-QC." On the E. face, EC. and an English name almost illegible. These, it need hardly be said, were modern embellishments.

3. A column on Cape Negro, long. 11° 53′ 54′′ E., Greenwich, lat. 15° 40′ 30′′ S., erected in 1485. According to MM. Cecille and Rudzky ('Annales Maritimes, 1137; Annaes do Conselho Ultra

2. A column dedicated to S. Cruz or S. Gregorio, generally asserted to have been erected on St. Croix (Cape Colony) in 1487. M. Castilho, after a careful collation of the accounts of the voyage, &c. of Mesquita Perestrello, who was despatched to visit this coast in 1575, is disposed to place it on the point of Cape Padrone (Padrão) long. 26° 35′ E., Greenwich, lat. 33° 45' S.; but he admits that the data are insufficient to enable us to arrive at any certain conclusion.

3. A column named after S. Filippe, chronologically the last erected by Diaz. Date, 1487. Site, indisputably the Cape of Good Hope itself.

been placed there on return voyage of Vasco da Gama.

It may be observed, that other monuments besides those above described were erected at this period. Casal ('Chorographia Brasilica') gives the sites of five upon the coast of South America. Barrós and other writers describe one erected upon the coast of Galle, in Ceylon, in 1506, to commemorate the "discovery" of that island by Dom L. d'Almeida. Others were also erected between the years 1508 and 1523, upon the islands of Sunda, Amboyna, and Banda, and on the coast of Java.

The columns erected by Vasco da Gama probably differed little from the above. They are believed to have borne two escutcheons-one containing the quinas, or five small escutcheons placed crosswise which form the centre charge of the arms of Portugal; and the other, the "armillary sphere" of Dom Manuel, besides inscriptions. They were six in number.

The reader will probably agree with Senhor Castilho, that these memorials, worthy of a great age of discovery, afford a striking contrast with the fragile bottles containing small slips of written memoranda which have taken their place with the explorers of later years. H. M. C.

1. A column erected in Mossel Bay (Cape Colony) on 6th November, 1497. Barrós mentions a column near Quillimane as the first erected by Vasco, and numerous subsequent writers have repeated the assertion. M. Castilho, however, considers it an established fact that a column was placed in the immediate neighbourhood of Cape St. Blaise, although it was probably destroyed soon afterwards by the natives, whose hostility caused Vasco to quit the place sooner than he had purposed.

Literary Gossip.

WE have great pleasure in laying before our readers the following important letter from Mr. Halliwell:

2. A column named after his ship, the S. Rafael, which all writers agree in placing in long. 37° 1' E., Greenwich, lat. 18° 1' 25" S., on the banks of the river Misericordia (probably a branch of the Zambezi), a little to the south of Quillimane. Date,

1498.
3. S. Espirito. Date, 1498.
River.

Mouth of Melinda

Worthing, August 9, 1870. A discovery I have recently made of a series of documents can hardly fail to interest many of your readers. They reveal the long-hidden mystery of the story of the establishment of the Globe and Blackfriars theatres. In the course of a long experience no papers have come to my hands which dissipate such a mass of conjecture, and throw 80 much new light upon the history of the Elizabethan stage. It is now certain that Shakespeare, who is more than once alluded to by name, was never a proprietor in either theatre. His sole interest in them consisted in a participation, as an actor, in the receipts of "what is called the house." This technical expression I do not recollect to have met with elsewhere, and it is at present a tiresome obstacle to the complete understanding of the position held by the great dramatist. Any one who can explain it would confer a real obligation. Does the phrase still linger in the theatrical vocabulary?

4. S. Gabriel. Date, 1498. At Calicut. 5. S. Maria. Date, 1498. Probably on the "Moolky Rocks" of Imray's Chart of Indian Ocean (1863). Long. 74° 35′ 24′′ E., Greenwich, lat. 13° 24' N.

6. S. Jorge. Date, 1499. Long. 40° 48′ 29′′ E., Greenwich, lat. 14° 57' 20" S. On an island in Mozambique. Supposed by M. Castilho to have

J. O. HALLIWELL.

A VOLUME of Essays, by Prof. Seeley, collected from magazines, is to be published in the autumn, when Prof. Seeley's lectures on Roman History will also appear.

of his edition of Plato-which may be expected WE understand that after the publication shortly-Prof. Jowett purposes to devote himself to a theological work.

WE submit the following Parisian mot to the consideration of Mr. Disraeli. A dramatic author accosts a critic, who had written a severe notice on the former's play, in the following terms :-"Vous éreintez ma pièce, et vous ne seriez seulement pas capable d'en écrire une scène."--"Pardon, cher monsieur, mais pourtant à la cour d'assises, le juré qui condamne n'est pas précisément forcé d'avoir commis le crime."

THE Rev. George Gilfillan is engaged on a new 'Life of Sir Walter Scott.' It will be published by Messrs. Oliphant, of Edinburgh.

In the Marquis of Lothian's volume of early Anglo-Saxon Homilies, the date of 971 A.D. has been found, but whether it is the date of the author or copier is not yet determined.

AN American Professor, who rejoices in the name of Sophocles, has published a lexicon of Greek of the Roman and Byzantine periods, which, according to the New York Nation, will "smite awe into the hearts of Tregelles and Tischendorf and Lachman." As we have not yet seen Prof. Sophocles' Dictionary, we cannot tell what effect it may produce on Dr. Tregelles or Dr. Tischendorf, but it must be

an extraordinary work if it affects Lachmann, as that great scholar died in 1851.

We also learn from the Nation, that Prof. Goodwin, of Harvard College, is editing an English version of Plutarch's Moralia,' founded upon the English versions of 1684-94, and the earlier one of 1603-57. An introductory essay by Mr. Emerson will be prefixed to the book, which will be in five volumes. THE first part of the Rev. W. W. Skeat's new edition of 'Barbour's Brus' will be ready in September.

THE public meeting of the five Academies of the French Institute, which was to have been held on the 13th of August, is postponed. WE hear that the able article on The Text of Chaucer,' in the last number of the Edinburgh Review, is from the pen of Prof. Baynes, of St. Andrews.

M. HECTOR MALOT has published another novel 'Une Bonne Affaire.' This is the third novel M. Malot has written within twelve months. Among other new novels we have 'Le Roman d'un libre Penseur,' by Mme. Audebert, and 'Un Millionnaire,' &c., by M. A. Assolant. THE Government of Madras have returned thanks to those gentlemen who have voluntarily undertaken to prepare lists of Sanskrit manuscripts. It is to be regretted there is only one non-official among them, Mr. Margochis, the Principal of the Trichinopoly High School.

PUBLICATIONS on the old French Revolution

continue. Two of the latest are M. Mortimer Ternaux's 'Massacres of September' (Sept. 2—6, 1792), and M. V. Delarue's 'First Disorders in Lille and its Environs, March to December, 1789.'

M. V. BOUTON has lately produced at Paris a fac-simile in folio, with comments, of a MS. illustration of a joust held at Tournay, in the year 1350.

THE Duc de Broglie's posthumous 'Views on the Government of France' has been edited by his son.

ONE sign of Denmark's looking to France

before the war is M. G. Brandes's work on M. Taine and modern French Esthetics, 'Den Franske Esthetik i vore Dage, en afhandling om H. Taine.' Another excellent Danish work we ought to have noticed earlier, The Life and Writings of Brunetto Latino,'-which, and not Latini, is the true form,-by Thor Sundby. It is a work of much research, done by a man who thinks for himself.

[ocr errors]

WE understand that Mr. Francis Parkman, of Boston, U.S., is engaged in preparing a new edition of his History of the Conspiracy of Pontiac, and the War of the North-American Tribes against the English Colonies after the Conquest of Canada.' This work, which was published as far back as 1851, will, in the new edition, be considerably augmented by materials obtained through a careful examination of the Bouquet and Haldimand collection of MS. documents which relate to the period of history in question, and were presented to the

British Museum in 1857.

HERR GUSTAV FREYTAG is one of the four German writers who are allowed to accompany the Prussian armies, in order to chronicle the events of the present campaign. THE funeral obsequies of M. Prévost-Paradol were celebrated, on the 8th instant, at the

Church of Notre-Dame-de-Lorette. The Académie was represented by M. Jules Sandeau and M. Patin. The discourse at the grave was pronounced by the former.

WE are advised from Valencia (Spain) that an important historical work is in the press, and will be shortly published, the subject being the "Germanias of Valencia" (the Junta which conspired against Charles the Fifth). The important documents now promised have been jealously guarded from inspection by succeeding governments; the last revolution having opened to historical students the archivos of the Crown and the Cathedral, the above mised volume is the result to be followed probably by many more of value to the historical student, anxious to verify those portions of less of facts." the history of Spain "written to order, regard

pro

be translated into French.
MR. MARSHMAN'S 'History of India' is to

A MALAY anthology has been begun by the Royal Institute for the Philology, Geography and Natural History of Netherlands India. The editor is Mr. G. K. Nieman, and the first part has already appeared in an 8vo. volume of above 300 pages.

THE first book of the Iliad has been translated into modern Greek verse by M. A. Khristopoulos.

SIGNOR ALBERTO MARIO has published at Mantua a very useful little volume, entitled

'Dante e i codici Danteschi.'

SIGNOR GIACOMO LOMBROSO has just published with important additions his recent work, 'Researches on the Political Economy of Egypt under the Lagidæ,' which received a prize from the Académie des Inscriptions et

des Belles-Lettres at Paris.

ON 21st of July a competitive examination was held in Sanskrit and Arabic for twentyfour scholarships in the Punjab University at Lahore. The scholars are to devote themselves to mathematics, history and geography, as well as English and oriental studies.

IN our last number, it should have been stated, that the first part of the second volume of Tischendorf's Greek Testament (eighth edition) had just appeared; and that both and B could not be properly used in the seventh edition.

ROYAL POLYTECHNIC.-Prof. Pepper's New Lecture, showing how the marvellous GHOST EFFECTS are produced.-New Musical Entertainment, by George Buckland, The Wicked Uncle; or, Hushbye-Babes in the Wood.'-'Sand and the Suez Canal.'-American Organ daily. The whole for One Shilling.

SCIENCE

Primitive Man. By Louis Figuier.

Revised

Translation. (Chapman & Hall.) Flint Chips. A Guide to Pre-Historic Archeology, as illustrated by the Collection in the Blackmore Museum, Salisbury. By Edward T. Stevens. (Bell & Daldy.) Grave-Mounds and their Contents: a Manual of Archaeology as exemplified in the Burials of the Celtic, the Romano-British, and the Anglo-Saxon Periods. By Llewellyn Jewitt, F.S.A. (Groombridge & Sons.) THE three books, of which the titles are given

above, are evidences of the interest which pre-
vails at the present time as to the early his-
tory of man.
The first of these is a popular

résumé of all that has been written on the subject; the second is an excellent catalogue of one of the finest collections existing of the early races of men; while the third is a valuable guide to a knowledge of the arts, the habits, and the occupations of the primitive inhabitants of these islands as illustrated by the contents of their graves.

There are many mysteries surrounding the origin of the human species. If we bring the question to the test of the evidences accumulated by the historical researches which peculiarly distinguish the present century, we find ourselves compelled to admit that there is unmistakable marks-as Bunsen especially has shown-that man's works have endured for not less than 20,000 years. The sermons in stones, however, which the geologist has taught us to read, lead us back still deeper into the dark arcana of time, and in geological formations belonging to ages far more remote than those which we call historical we dis

cover relics which can only be interpreted to indicate that the human animal then lived --not as an isolated individual—or as a single pair-but as groups of men and womencarrying on the battle of life over the plains of Europe and Asia. It is impossible to reconcile the hypothesis, which gives to man's creation a period no further removed from the present time than 7,000 years, with that view which gives at least 20,000 years to his being—or ological evidence which cannot reach a beginwith the deductions from geological and archæning, but which discovers nomadic racesmaking rude weapons, with much ingenuity, from well-selected stones, with which to slay the beasts of the forests for food, or to defend themselves from the attacks of their enemies:

these primitive men, be it remembered, dwelling upon lands which were yet subject to those great catastrophes which have brought our continents and islands to their present physical conditions.

It cannot but be evident to every one, who will dispassionately examine the flint implements and the bone tools found in the Drift formations, that they indicate the efforts of thought of rude races of men, whose mental powers were slowly being awakened by the necessities of the conditions in which they were placed. The conditions under which these relics are found being such, that none but those who perversely close their eyes to the glimmer of light which they afford, can doubt that they indicate an antiquity which cannot be reached by what we call historic time. It is not possible, in this place, to sketch out the attempts which have been made to reconcile that which is regarded as the teachings of inspiration and the whisperings of nature. M. Figuier has attempted this, and to his work we must refer our readers; but it must He has only collected together the evidences not be thought that he has solved the problem. which modern researches have accumulated; and this he has done with a considerable the inquiry respecting Primitive Man from amount of care. He endeavours to separate the Mosaic story of man's creation, by trying to prove to his readers that the question of the origin and age of man is independent of all not assume that the authority of Holy Writ is subordination to dogma, and that we must aim at seeking the real epoch of man's first in any way questioned by those labours which appearance upon earth.

M. Figuier divides the history of Primitive Man into two great epochs-the Stone age and the Metal age. These he again subdivides, as follows:-The Stone age into three epochs. First: the epoch of extinct animals. Secondly, the epoch of migrated existing animals. Thirdly, the epoch of domesticated existing animals. The Metal age into two periods: first, the Bronze epoch; secondly, the Iron epoch. It has always appeared to us that these divisions are of the most arbitrary character. It cannot have escaped observation that the use of stone implements, though commenced, beyond doubt, when the world was young, has been continued by divisions of the human race, through all times even to the most recent. The divisions into a bronze and an iron age is still more objectionable, since no evidence has yet been given of any people using bronze alone, and to whom the value of iron was unknown. M. Figuier has well selected such evidence as does exist.

The great question which is now incessantly obtruded upon us-was man created complete in all his parts and independent of the animals which existed before him? or is he derived from any other animal species, particularly from the ape?-occupies much space in this work. Man, argues M. Figuier, in his first state cannot have been much distinguished from the brute, his only effort being to ensure his daily subsistence. His pillow was a stone; his roof was the shadow of some widespreading tree; or of some dark cavern, which was also his refuge from the beasts of prey. But progress is the law of man's existence. Man's state has always been improving: that of the brute has remained without change. Our author attempts the refutation of the theory which derives the human species from the ape:

"Is there," he asks, "nothing in man but bones? Do the skeleton and the viscera make up the entire sum of the human being? What will you say then, ye blind rhetoricians, about the faculty of intelligence as manifested in the gift of speech? Intelligence and speech, these are really the attributes which constitute man, these are the qualities which make him the most complete being in creation, and the most privileged of God's creatures. Show me an ape who can speak, and then I will agree with you in recognising it as a fact that man is nothing but an improved ape. Show me an ape who can make flint hatchets and arrow-heads-who can light a fire and cook his food, who, in short, can act like an intelligent creature,-then, and then only, I am ready to confess that I am nothing more than an orang-outang revised and corrected!"

Those remarks will sufficiently indicate the character of this book. It is interesting, and essentially popular. Though the author speaks with authority, it must be remembered he has no claim to do so. He is not an investigator: his highest position is that of an industrious and careful compiler. Those who take an interest in the subject of 'Primitive Man,' will find his story, as told by M. Figuier, a pleasing one. Here is an interesting book, with 263 illustrations, of which thirty are page engravings, which are confessed in the preface "to be somewhat fanciful in their style, but will be found on examination that they are, in the main, justified by that soundest evidence, the actual discovery of the objects of which they represent the use."

The city of Salisbury possesses, in the Blackmore Museum, the finest collection of stone implements and other objects, illustrating

something of the life of our aborigines, to be
found in the world. Mr. Stevens has added
greatly to its value, by the production of
Flint Chips,' which we have no hesitation
in saying, is one of the most perfect descriptive
Catalogues which we have ever examined.
A more satisfactory guide to the study of that
so-called science of pre-historic archæology
cannot be found,-it being a record of facts,
rather than an exposition of speculative theories.
Mr. William Blackmore, who established the
Museum which bears his name, as an ex-
tension of the Salisbury and South Wilts
Museum, remarked, in his address on the
occasion of its opening, "the one great lesson
which I conceive to be taught by my collection
is progress." This idea, necessarily implies a
starting-point, and it is conceived by the
author of Flint Chips,' that the chipped
flint implements found in the valley gravels
furnish us with the starting-point of human
thought and invention. Upon this basis the
collection at Salisbury is arranged; and upon
this hypothesis the "Guide" has been written.
Four groups form the great general divisions:
the first being the remains of animals found
associated with the works of man; the second
being implements of stone; the third imple-
ments of bronze; and the fourth, a most
valuable group, the implements, weapons
and ornaments of Modern Savages, which serve
to throw light upon the use of similar objects
belonging to pre-historic times.

Perhaps, in the uncertainty surrounding
this most interesting inquiry, it is not easy to
adopt a better classification. But, in reading
the story of progress as illustrated by this and
similar collections, we must never forget that
the "stone age "exists to the present day,
and extends back into the deep clouds of
antiquity. Stone implements were, without
doubt used by the savage man in his most
uncultivated condition; but, we do know that
flint chips were also employed by races who
had made considerable advances in true civili-
zation, and to whom implements of bronze and
iron were not unknown. The Jews may be
instanced as an example of this, and the
myriads of flint flakes found on the flanks of
the Sinaian mountains, known to the Arabs as
"Jews' knives," may be accepted as evidences
of the correctness of our statement. The
catalogue before us indeed gives most con-
clusive testimony, and shows that the divisions
into a stone and bronze age cannot be marked
by even a shadowy line of division. In adopt-
ing the division of a bronze age, for example,
all archæologists appear to have forgotten one
thing, which certainly shows that the men
who made bronze implements or weapons
belonged to races possessing considerable
capacity of thought, who had cultivated habits
of observation, and studied with much care
the conditions of some natural objects, by
a process of induction: that is, they arrived
at their results after many experimental trials.
In the first place, a knowledge of metallurgy
must have existed before the metals, copper and
tin, could have been separated from their ores:
and secondly, a careful study of alloys must
have been made, before the correct proportion
of tin could have been ascertained, with which
to give the copper the requisite degree of
hardness-without brittleness-for a cutting
instrument. Pre-historic Archæology is at
present formed of hypotheses, and nearly all

of those demand a much more extended ex-
amination of facts than they have yet received
before they can be raised above the class of
guesses. The Blackmore Museum is calculated
to do much for this division of Archæology,
and, read by the light of Mr. Stevens's guide,
'Flint Chips,' those "minor monuments
of the earlier inhabitants of this earth, will
serve to give an exactness to the future study
of the progress of human thought, which has
not hitherto been secured for it.

[ocr errors]

'Grave-Mounds' comes most appropriately to aid the study which has been introduced by the two books already noticed. Mr. Llewellyn Jewitt has done good service in producing this book. It is the only work of its kind that has ever been issued, which records the almost endless store of hitherto undigested knowledge presented by the varied relics of the grave-mounds of the three great divisions of the history of these islands.

The subject is treated in a popular manner, divested of technicalities, avoiding all theories, and without the introduction of discursive matter. We have in 'Grave-Mounds' a record of the researches which have been made into the graves of the Celt-and perhaps of a people earlier than the Celts of the Romans, and of the Anglo-Saxons. Let us hope that two such works as those produced by Mr. Stevens and Mr. Jewitt may induce a more careful and exact study of "Pre-historic Archæology" than that which has hitherto prevailed, and which is especially illustrated in the fanciful sketches which adorn the pages of the translation of the poetical work of M. Louis Figuier.

REPORT OF THE ASTRONOMER ROYAL FOR
SCOTLAND.

THE Report of the Astronomer Royal for Scotland to the Board of Visitors of the Royal Observatory, Edinburgh, is now before us. The Report contains an account of a series of experiments undertaken, during the last year, in order to ascertain if pos sible the cause of a yearly fluctuation in azimuth and level, which has been long known to take place in the transit instrument of the Edinburgh Observatory. Prof. Smyth traces the source of this fluctuation to the physical quality of the stone employed in the construction of the piers. The heat, radiated from hand-lamps placed in the neighbourhood, was ascertained to have an unusually great effect in disturbing the piers, and this result is further verified by the fact that the stone comes from the Craigleith quarry, the expansion by heat of which stone Prof. Smyth informs us, was found by the late Alexander Adie to be as great as that of cast-iron. Its conductibility for heat was also shown by the late Principal Forbes to be great. The effect of radiating heat on the piers is shown by the experiments of Prof. Smyth to be so great and so rapid that very great precautions seem necessary for avoiding, or rather regu lating, these effects, so as to give anything like a reasonable probability of their consequent error being at all times accurately known.

We regret much to see that the Government have still deferred considering the estimates for the Edinburgh Equatorial. The equatorial is daily ment in an observatory, owing to the immense growing to be a more and more necessary instruadvances which are being made in the use of the spectroscope and of the thermopile. Every new equatorial which can be put into the hands of competent observers is sure at the present time to confer real benefit on science. One good observa

tory may be sufficient for keeping the time, but light of the heavenly bodies. It is exceedingly we need a hundred for investigating the heat and desirable that all private observatories, instead of repeating needless meridional observations, should,

« PreviousContinue »