P 145 (E 474): hab. P (no note); om. cet.

P 585 (formula): om. ABM1GT1YP1Qd (om. ir ABCGeTV32); hab. SM2NJT2.

P 683a (= 118): hab. HPU (hab. ¡M3); om. cet.

* 200-1 (= A 800-1, II 42-3) om. NJ; hab. A; 201 om. SDbTCECQdRZZÁY1 (no notes).

* 381 (= 16+ 127 etc.): om. A1S1NGUb1YP (om. AGEL10L11N1U2U1U11V10V16); hab. A2 (èv ädλw kai oυtos evρélŋ, áñéστραπτο δέ Ar) S2Ub2Ω.

*Σ 427 ( = = 196): om. ΣGH1 (om. PoirGeV1o); hab. AH2. *T 19a (adaptation of formula): hab. HEQd et im. G3 (hab. ilq DL L12M); om. cet.

T 177 (= I 276): om ΣSD1NGHJYLHEьKcQdUdY¢A2 (om. vulg.); hab. BMTU PCF2NьXYZ (hab. bcef BN1N✩V1V16).

T 361a (= II 267): hab. PC1Ob (hab. bq V32); om. cet. Y 3a hab. M2Ec; om. cet. (no note).

Y 135 (211): om. S1BMNJT P¤UbYbL1HbPEb1C1NbRUDY1Y (om. vulg.); hab. ZAGHQbCbObXZZ (vóbos im. X) et im. S3L2Eb2C2Y2 (hab. 9 bdipq A).

Y 2232 (= Hes. Th. 279): hab. Eb°C (hab. 1); om. cet. Y 224a (idem): hab. M3PY et. im. G2Z2 (hab. g M&M10V10); om. ASM1Z1ZPN.

Y 312 ( X 176): om. ASBM1NGHUы1YыLHbQbEb1UdY (om.bghipr ABCDV82); hab. M2JPxUb2PEb2XYCZP.

Y 447 (= II 705): om. S1NHJTUbYbLHP1Y1Z (om. vulg.); hab. AEˇBMPÕE¢XZP et im. S3P2Y2 (èv äddois ó σTÍXOS OUTOS OÙ KEITαι Ar) (hab. bcpq ABCN1).

96a: hab. Σ (hab. ); om. cet.

158 ( B 850): om. ZASNG1H1TPL1P1Y (om. P iopr A Ang. N1U2U÷V32); hab. BMG2H2JYLHÓP2XYZ.

434 (= A 595): om. ASBMH1UbiQbEbUdi (om. eil ABCDN1O V1V12); hab. NGTYLHьCE¢FzXYZ et im. H2Ub2 PUd2.

480 ( B 277): om. ASBMNGJTY LHPQbEbZp (om. vulg.); hab. HUbEcFzXUUdXYZ (hab. gipq Mc).

Þ 510 (= E 374): om. ΣAS1BMNHUb1YLHьQbEbUа (om. pcdhklp ABCDO5V32); hab. GJTPE XYZZ et im. S3 Ub2

*X 10a (= ▲ 33): hab. Σ (hab. o); om. N.

*X 121 (512): om. ASHZP (om. npr ADM10U V1); hab. BMNJUbYbLHьPXYZ.

X 316 (T 383): om. A1S1HUd, Par. (om. i AD); hab.

ΣΩ.

X 330a (=O 48): hab. P; om. cet. (no note).

*⇓ 565 ( 624, 797): om. ΣABMHTPU et it. UbYZ (om. bgk ABCN1TV1V16V32); hab. SNGJY»H»QbXY¢Z.

*⇓ 628a (✔ ▲ 669): hab. Ub; om. cet.

(no note).

* 804: om. A1SG1T1PUU (om. o AL1oL16L 20 N4U11V1 1011121824); hab. BMNo et im. A2G2T2.

* 864 (= 873, A 102): om. SNT et, v. Ludw. ad 866, B2 (om. gL10L15O3TU2U4V32); hab. AB1.

* 558 ( 388 +K 498): om. SG1TPxYbLUdZp (om. bDGfTU3U9U11V11011423); hab. A (oυTOS & σTixos oux εὑρέθη ἐν τῷ παλαιῷ Ar) BMGΖΩ.

* 693 (= 434, 2): om. ASNGJTEыY1, Angel., Barberin., Crypt., Vat. 915 (om. aflo A Ang. Gf. V11V32); hab. BMDCHYbHbPXZZP et Y2 im.

* 790 (= A 57): om. AD¢TYbLHьUUdYZZP, Barberin., Crypt. (om. bceg AGfN1TV32); hab. SBMNHJUbExPEьXYc. There remain a number of passages in which the disturbance of the manuscript tradition is not so marked. It is possible that in some the disturbance is secondary and accidental. In other cases, however, it seems probable that the harmony of the manuscripts is secondary, having been brought about by the assimilation of the manuscripts in the later stages of the tradition.

*B 141 (= I28): no note (om. V32) ev Tiσiv où péperai sch. T. *г 78 ( = H 56): om. AG1 (om. AGEN V15); hab. G2 im., cet. *r 235 om. it. Db1 (om. M5O5); hab. Db2 im., cet.

*▲ 196–7 (= 206-7): om. SD1YbNa1, vm. 197 solum om. J (om. o); hab. cet. et im. D2Na2.

E 808 (828, A 390): no note (om. LV16).

H 234 (I 644, A 465): om. it., add. im. A (om. AU1); v. 1. N 824: DbFYhCEcU1Wb1, cum ouтws P im. (gr L12 V: utrumque [ordine inverso] Ang. V18V29).

H 385 (327): om. A1K1 (om. AU2V3V12Vi1); hab. A1o (s. p. DK); pro ἀριστῆες Παναχαιῶν: ἐυκνήμιδες Αχαιοί Απ (èv ädλw) SGUbYbHbQ2Qc2UU¢Wb (abdo NoN4P1V1V15).

* 6 (formula): om. AS1Px (om. cd ADU1V1 al.); hab. S3ΒΜΩ.

* 315 (= 123): om. it. AGK, add. im. AG K2; s. p. (ut K2) it. Db (no note).

℗ 458 (= ▲ 21): om. B1M1GL (om. eh BCU2V32); hab. B3M2, s. p. DK3.

* 12 (= K 135 etc.): om. Px, ante II pos. Ub1, cr. Ub2.

* 420 (N 544+ M 396, N 181): om. A1; hab. A20 (no note).

*0 562 (= E 530): om. S1NTUbi PC1UYZ (om. bg); hab. AZP et im. S3Ub2C2.

*O 578 (formula): om. GHP-Ub1Ud(om. e L1oV1V10V32); hab. § Ub2 im.; Tòv dè σKÓTOS Őσσe káλvev EbQdZN (flpr ABCΝ'), ἀράβησε δὲ τεύχε' ἐπ' αὐτῷ SD NTXYY (vulg.).

P 74 (formula): om. T (no note).

*P 219 (formula): om. S1NJTY LECY (no note); nota' signatus A, hab. § et im. S2P.

P 455 (= A 194): om. BM1Yh1 PR (om. fr BC al.); hab. M20; deest A1.

*2 44I (= 60): om. G (om. Ge); & riu oủ KÉTại A.

73 (formula): no note (om. V32).

*X 363 (= II 857): om. S1 (om. V1); add. et S3 im.

An older stage of the tradition is represented by the 'vulgate papyri'-under which term are included, with the exception of the four papyri specified in A. J. P. XXXV, p. 128, all the papyri written after the middle of the second century before our era. Of these I give a list as complete as possible. Some material has been inaccessible: the publication of the Società Italiana, Papiri greci e latini; Sitzb. d. Heidelberger Akad., 1914, 2. Abth. (said to contain a few lines of A); and Bull. de La Soc. d'Alexandrie, No. 14, tom. III (containing B 381-92). Even apart from this, as the material is widely scattered, it is probable that something has escaped me. Still the list is longer than those previously published, because compiled in view of a different purpose, which renders even the smallest scrap of value. The arrangement is also different, being intended primarily to show exactly what evidence we have, or have not, for each line of the poem.

A: P. Oxyrh. 534, S. III, 1-15; P. Brit. Mus. 129, 37-54. 65-7. 207-229; P. Oxyrh. 535, S. III, 43-59; P. Genav. 3,1 44-60; P. Berol. 6869. 7492-5, S. I-II, 70-104. 114-23. 412-33.

'Nicole, Rev. de Phil. XVIII, p. 103.

456-65. 494-590; P. Oxyrh. 748, S. III, 107–16; P. Rylands 43, S. III, 121-57. 161–99. 202–41. 244-84; P. Oxyrh. 536, S. III, 127-47; P. Oxyrh. 749, S. II, 160–76; P. Berol. 9813, S. II-III, 164-181; P. Oxyrh. 537, S. II-III, 215-20. 250-66; P. Fayum 141, S. I-II, 273-362; P. Oxyrh. 538, S. III, 273–97. 318-42; P. Tebt. 425, S. II, 311-27; P. Greco-Egiz. II. 106, S. III, 370-405. 428-76 (with lacunae); P. Fayum 5, S. II, 404-47; P. Berol. 10574, S. IV, 406-19; P. Berol. 9584, S. I, 449-61; P. Rylands 44, S. I A. C., 471-80. 495-506; cod. Bodl. Ms. Gr. class. a. 1 (P),1 S. II, 506-7; P. Oxyrh. 539, S. II, 575-83.

Lines uncovered: 16-36. 61-4. 68-9. 105-6. 158-9. 200-1. 242-3. 363-9. 481–94. 591–611. ·

B 1-493: cod. Bodl. Ms. Gr. class. a. 1 (P), complete; P. Chicag. 5, S. II, 1-20; P. Tebt. 426, S. II, 33–7. 46–52. 55–60; P. Oxyrh. 686, S. I A. C., 50-8; P. Oxyrh. 750, S. III, 5773; P. Tebt. 4, S. II A. C., 95–109. (110-1 inferred from space). 112-5. 121-57. 172-87. 197-210; P. Brit. Mus. 126,2 S. IV-V, 101-493 (but 125-51 undecipherable); P. Berol. Inv. Nr. 13839, S. IV, 132-62; P. Rylands 45, S. II, 327-33; P. Tebt. 265, S. II, 339-46. 360-3; P. Oxyrh. 944, S. III, 436-44.

B 494-877: cod. Bodl. Ms. Gr. class. a. 1 (P) complete; P. Tebt. 265, S. II, 507-80. 595-604. 638–52; P. Berol. 9583, S. II-III, 534-53; P. Fayum 309, S. II, 611-83; P. Oxyrh. 540, S. III, 672-83; P. Aberd. 1, 2, 687-95, 760-78; P. Oxyrh. 945, S. V, 722-41. 753-72; P. Oxyrh. 20, S. II, 730-6. 745-54. 769-810. 815-28; P. Oxyrh. 21, S. I-II, 745-64; P. GrecoEgizii II. 107, S. I A. C., 855-67; P. Oxyrh. 541, S. III, 85973; P. Oxyrh. 946, S. II-III, 861–7.

г: P. Brit. Mus. 126, cf. above, complete; P. Oxyrh. 751, S. II-III, 30-55; P. Berol. 10569, S. III, 174-94; P. Oxyrh. 687, S. I A. C., 185-9. 207-16; P. Fayum 209, S. I, 214-24; P. Berol. 263, S. IV-V, 280-9. 315-22. 351-63. 392-8; P. Brit.

1A. H. Sayce, in Hawara, Biahmu and Arsinoe, by W. Flinders Petrie, 1889, pp. 24-8. Assigned by Allen to the fifth century. I depend on Ludwich.

'According to Ludwich: partem (248-304) edidit Wessely, Bemerkungen zu einigen Publicationen auf dem Gebiete der älteren gr. Palaeographie, Wien, 1892. Class. Quart. 1907. 257 ff.

Mus. 136, S. III, 317-37. 345-72; P. Tebt. 427, S. II-III, 33863. 386-97; P. Oxyrh. 543, S. II-III, 361-77; P. Oxyrh. 542, S. III, 371-418; P. Greco-Egiz. II. 108, S. III, 397–408. 411-22.

A: P. Brit. Mus. 136, S. III, 1-28. 56-69. 74-9. 111-50. 15992. 198-201. 208-45. 256-93. 303-45. 352-544; P. Brit. Mus. 126, cf. above, 1-40; P. Berol. 7808, S. II-III, 1-13. 35-9; P. Berol. 7116. 7117. 7119, S. III, 27–53. 137–238. ; P. Genav. 4 (cf. above), 82-95; P. Oxyrh. 752, S. III, 87-96; P. Oxyrh. 544, S. III, 182-98; P. Cairo (Sayce, Acad. 1894, p. 401), 191-219; P. Aberd. 3, 199-211; P. Rylands 46, S. I, 357-64; P. Oxyrh. 753, S. III, 364-98; P. Oxyrh. 947, S. III, 443-52; P. Jandan. 93, S. I A. C., 454–66. 483–8; P. Oxyrh. 545, S. II-III, 478– 90; P. Oxyrh. 754, S. I, 532-9.

Lines uncovered: 54-6. 70-73. 80-1. 97-110. 246-55. 294302. 346-51.

E: P. Oxyrh. 223, S. III, 1–278. 284-303. 329-74 397-406. 420-42. 544-8. 701-5. (332. 352. 422-4 inferred from space); P. Tebt. 428, S. II-III, 52–5; P. Berol. 8440, S. I, 69–81. 84-93. 103; P. Oxyrh. 755, S. III, 130-73; P. Rylands 47, S. II, 216– 60; P. Oxyrh. 756, S. III-IV, 324-34. 379–90; P. Amherst 22, S. I-II, 481-95; P. Oxyrh. 757, S. I, 578-86; P. Oxyrh. 758, S. II-III, 583-96; P. Rylands 48, S. III, 648-81. 684–96. 704-11; P. Oxyrh. 759, S. III, 662-82; P. Oxyrh. 760, S. I, 715-8. 720-9; P. Brit. Mus. 127, 731-4. 815-8. 846-50; P. Chicag. 6, S. II, 824-41.

Lines uncovered: 279-83. 304-23. 375-8. 391-6. 407-19. 443-80. 496-543. 549-77. 597-647. 683. 697–700. 712–4. 719. 730. 735-814. 819-23. 842-5. 851-909.

Z: P. Paris.,1 S. I A. C., 1-39; P. Brit. Mus. 127, 90-100. 119-25; P. Oxyrh. 445, S. II-III, 134-7. 173-99. 445-529 (195-8. 483-4. 501-2. 505-6. 511-2. 514-7 inferred from space); P. Oxyrh. 761, S. I A. C., 147–9; P. Genav. 5, 327–53. Lines uncovered: 40-89. 101-18. 126-33. 138-46. 150-72. 200-326. 354-444

H: P. Oxyrh. 762, S. III, 1-35; P. Aberd. 4, 60-8; P. Oxyrh. 763, S. III, 68–101. 69-134 (?); P. Oxyrh. 546, S. II, 237-44. 264–73; P. Oxyrh. 547, S. II-III, 324-36. 357–63. Lines uncovered: 36-59. 135-236. 245-63. 274-323. 337-56. 364-482.

'Published by A. de Longpérier, cf. Silvestre, Paléogr. Universelle, II (1840), p. 210.