sels 5

REPORTS

OF

CASES IN LAW AND EQUITY,

DETERMINED IN THE

SUPREME COURT

OF THE

STATE OF IOWA.

BY JOHN S. RUNNELLS,

REPORTER.

VOL. XV,

BEING VOLUME LII OF THE SERIES.

BANKS & BROTHERS, LAW PUBLISHERS,
NEW YORK: No. 144 NASSAU STREET.

ALBANY, N. Y.: 473 AND 475 BROADWAY.

1880.

Entered according to an Act of Congress, in the year 1880, for the State

of Iowa,

J. A. T. HULL, SECRETARY of State,

In the Office of the Librarian of Congress, Washington, D. C.

Rec. Dec. 14, 1880

MILLS & COMPANY,
STEREOTYPERS,
DES MOINES, IOWA.

JUDGES AND OFFICERS OF THE SUPREME COURT

AS AT PRESENT CONSTITUTED.

HON. AUSTIN ADAMS, Dubuque, Chief Justice.
WILLIAM H. SEEVERS, Oskaloosa,
JAMES G. DAY, Sidney,

66

66

66

JAMES H. ROTHROCK, Tipton,

Judges.

46

JOSEPH M. BECK, Fort Madison,

CLERK.

EDWARD J. HOLMES, Maquoketa.

ATTORNEY GENERAL.

J. F. McJUNKIN, Washington.

REPORTER.

JOHN S. RUNNELLS, Des Moines.

JUDGES OF THE DISTRICT AND CIRCUIT COURTS.

1ST DISTRICT-ABRAHAM H. STUTSMAN, District Judge. J. B. DRAYER. Circuit Judge.

CHARLES H. PHELPS, Circuit Judge.

2D DISTRICT-EDWARD L. BURTON, District Judge. ROBERT SLOAN, Circuit Judge.

3D DISTRICT-R. C. HENRY, District Judge.

D. D. GREGORY. Circuit Judge.

4TH DISTRICT-CHARLES H. LEWIS, District Judge.
J R. ZUVER, Circuit Judge.

5TH DISTRICT-WM. H. McHENRY, District Judge.
JOHN MITCHELL, Circuit Judge.
S. A. CALLVERT, Circuit Judge.

6TH DISTRICT-JOHN C. COOK, District Judge.

LUCIEN C. BLANCHARD, Circuit Judge.
7TH DISTRICT-WALTER I. HAYES, District Judge.
DANIEL W. ELLIS, Circuit Judge.
DE WITT C. RICHMAN, Circuit Judge.

8TH DISTRICT-JOHN SHANE, District Judge.
JOHN MCKEAN, Circuit Judge.

9TH DISTRICT-SYLVESTER BAGG, District Judge. BENJAMIN W. LACY, Circuit Judge.

10TH DISTRICT-E. E. COOLEY, District Judge.

CHARLES T. GRANGER, Circuit Judge. 11TH DISTRICT-JAMES W. MCKENZIE, District Judge. JOHN H. BRADLEY, Circuit Judge. 12TH DISTRICT-GEORGE W. RUDDICK, District Judge. ROBERT G. REINIGER, Circuit Judge. BTH DISTRICT-JOSEPH R. REED, District Judge. C. F. LOOFBOUROW, Circuit Judge.

14TH DISTRICT-ED. R. DUFFIE, District Judge. JOHN N. WEAVER, Circuit Judge.