 Observed use of language or hypothesized dispositions to respond, habits, and so on, may provide evidence as to the nature of this mental reality, but surely cannot constitute the actual subject matter of linguistics, if this is to be a serious discipline.  Aspects of the Theory of Syntax - Page 4by Noam Chomsky - 1969 - 251 pagesLimited preview - About this book
 | Moshe Kroy - Philosophy - 1974 - 260 pages
...is mentalistic, since it is concerned with discovering a mental reality underlying actual behavior. Observed use of language or hypothesized dispositions...this is to be a serious discipline. The distinction 1 am noting here is related to the langue parole distinction of Saussure; but it is necessary to reject... | |
 | English language - 1981 - 532 pages
...is mentalistic, since it is concerned with discovering a mental reality underlying actual behavior. Observed use of language or hypothesized dispositions...linguistics, if this is to be a serious discipline. [Chomsky 1965, p.3] This passage touches upon several major postulates of transformational theory and... | |
 | Yosef Grodzinsky - Language Arts & Disciplines - 1990 - 224 pages
...is mentalistic, since it is concerned with discovering a mental reality underlying actual behavior. Observed use of language or hypothesized dispositions...linguistics, if this is to be a serious discipline, (p. 4) From the psychological angle, Fodor and Garrett (1966) made a very similar point: There is no... | |
 | Catherine Emmott - Language Arts & Disciplines - 1997 - 346 pages
...is mentalistic. since it is concerned with discovering a mental reality underlying actual behaviour. Observed use of language or hypothesized dispositions...linguistics, if this is to be a serious discipline.' 12 Sinclair and Coulthard (1975: 2) say that the two schools are 'diametrically opposed'. to a wholesale... | |
 | Lewis Edwin Hahn - Philosophy - 2000 - 622 pages
...concerned with discovering a mental reality underlying actual behavior. Observed use of language. . . may provide evidence as to the nature of this mental...linguistics, if this is to be a serious discipline" (1965: 4). He goes on to relate this delineation of his object domain with Saussure's distinction between... | |
 | Rens Bod, Jennifer Hay, Stefanie Jannedy - Language Arts & Disciplines - 2003 - 468 pages
...different from Chomsky's (1965, 4) stance that "observed use of language ... may provide evidence ... but surely cannot constitute the actual subject matter...linguistics, if this is to be a serious discipline." But there remains the question of how to interpret this datum, and here Chomsky's (1986) distinction... | |
 | Ukoro Theophilus Igwe - Philosophy - 2004 - 524 pages
...concerned with discovering a mental reality underlying actual behavior. Observed use of language... may provide evidence as to the nature of this mental...linguistics. if this is to be a serious discipline". CHOMSKY, N., Aspects of the Theory of Syntax, Cambridge. Mass.: MIT Press. 1965. p. 4. He goes on to... | |
 | Jesper Hoffmeyer - Science - 2008 - 290 pages
...[wrote Chomsky] since it is concerned with discovering a mental reality underlying actual behavior. Observed use of language or hypothesized dispositions...linguistics, if this is to be a serious discipline . . . [For] a record of natural speech will show numerous false starts, deviations from rules, changes... | |
 | Horst Arndt, Richard Wayne Janney - Language Arts & Disciplines - 1987 - 480 pages
...mentalistic, since it is concerned with discovering the mental reality underlying actual behavior. Observed use of language or hypothesized dispositions...on, may provide evidence as to the nature of this reality, but surely cannot constitute the actual subject matter of linguistics, if this is to be a... | |
| |
