and 120 New York State Reporter
8 5. Rights and liabilities of devisees The refusal of the court to allow -
and legatees.

to be asked a question in substantials the
In an action to establish the lien of a legacy, i form as one preceding, asked him and
it is incumbent on plaintiff to prove that it is during the same examination, is not caixin
a subsisting lien and remains unpaid.-Conk. reversal.-Deitch v. Feder (Sup.) 802.
ling v. Weatherwax (Sup.) 139.

$ 3. Credibility, impeachment, contre
Where a devisee under a will accepts the ben-

diction, and corroboration.
efit thereof, he will be bound by all the con- In an action for personal injuries, defe
terits of the instrument.--Beetson v. Stoops street railway held entitled to ask plass
(Sup.) 332.

passenger, on cross-examination, whether
Where will provides, after debts are paid, for knew that he must show that the car staan
legacy to wife in lieu of dower and other rights, while he was alighting, in order to shuFIT-
wife held entitled to payment of her claim in Kramer v. Metropolitan St. Ry. Co. (Splik
addition to legacy.-In re Spear's Will (Sup.) Vatter of cross-examination held not a
448.

al, but pertinent, and permitting of injer
Bequest to testator's wife in lieu of dower ment thereon.-V roman F. Kryn (Sup.) 94.
and statutory rights held not to entitle her, Plaintiff in an action for rent keld eotti
in case she rejects it, to legacy equal to dis on the issue of waiver by defendant of a m-
tributive share, if he had died intestate.-In re dition on which the lease was executed, to .
Spear's Will (Sup.) 418.

that defendant did what, on cross-erarios: 4
In partition, provision held properly made for he said he did not do.-Lurie v. Lery (Split
a legacy in lieu of dower, where the personalty Written statement of witness held pot od
failed.--Wilmot v. Robinson (Sup.) 575.

tionable, as rebutting uew matter called onto
Where testator, at the execution of his will, cross-examination.- l'erine v. Interurban da
was possessed of ample personalty to satisfy Co. (Sup.) 479.
legacies, the existence of a power of sale in An affidavit containing other statements :
the will is no reason for subjecting the real es- witness than those about which he was ges-
tate to the payment of legacies on an insuffi- tioned held inadmissible to contradict his tim?
ciency of the personalty.-Schuidt v. Limmer mony.-Leggett v. City of Watertowa SA
(Sup.) 057.

982.
Where a devise to a testator's widow of lands

Contradiction of party's own witness Ad!
is not in lieu of dower, the widow is entitled, have been on collateral matter, and there
as against a judgment creditor of the testator, error.-Wimmer v. Metropolitan St. Ry. (
to have the dower ascertained and deducted.- (Sup.) 1052.
Lauby v. Gill (Sup.) 718.

On an issue as to whether defendant 19?
In creditor's action against sole devisee of revoked his guaranty of notes, testimony of
lands of deceased debtor, who had sold them be- attorney as to his advice that defendant she
fore action brought, held, that devisee was en- do so held incompetent.-Lincoln Nat. Bank T.
titled to deduction to the amount of mortgages Fischer-Hansen (Sup.) 1093.
due thereon and taxes.-Lauby V. Gill (Sup.)
718.
WITNESSES.

WORK AND LABOR.
See "Evidence."

Liens for work and materials, see “Mechanis'

Liens."
Absence of, as ground for continuance, see “Con- Matters concluded by judgment in action for

tinuance."
Contracts to testify for per cent. of recovery.

services, see “Judginent," $ 5.
as affected by public policy, see “Contracts, In an action on a contract, which cannot !
$ 1.

upheld, because unconscionable, defendant pas
Discussion of facts with witness by referee, in prove the value of services, which plaintif bas

absence of counsel as ground for removal, see shown were rendered under the contract.-Has-
"Reference," $ 1.

kell v. Smith (Sup.) 779.
Experts, see' "Evidence," $ 8.
Opinions, see "Evidence," 8 8.
Witness fees as costs, see “Costs," $ 3.

WRITS.

See "Process."
$ 1. Competency.

Particular writs.
Witness held not interested in event of action,
and hence not disqualitied to testify to transac.

See “Execution”; “Injunction"; "Wandamus"

;!
tions with deceased, under Code Civ. Proc. $

"Replevin."
829, in action against executor.-Rosseau V.
Rouss (Sup.) 197.

WRONGS.

See “Torts."
$ 2. Examination.

In an action of conversion, witness held to
have been properly allowed to read from written

YEAR.
list of articles.-Meyert v. Reubman (Sup.) 797. Estates for years, see "Landlord and Tenant."

TABLES OF NEW YORK SUPPLEMENT CASES

APPEARING IN OTHER REPORTS.

VOL. 87, APPELLATE DIVISION REPORTS.

84

A.Div. N.Y. A. Div. N.Y. A. Div. N.Y. A. Div. N.Y. A.Div. N.Y. A.Div. N.Y. A. Div. N.Y. Rep. Supp. | Rep. Supp. Rep. Supp. Rep. Supp. Rep. Supp. | Rep. Supp. Rep. Supp. Pg. Vol Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. Pg. Vol. Pg. 1 83 1057 78 84 13 157 84 32 253 84 319 335 84

1001

430 84 506 543 84 830 8 83 1045 81 12 | 160 84 58 262 84 359

344 84 425 434 84 444550 84 13

1052 83 1091 83 83 1073 163

84 70 269 . 84 341 346 84 565 438 84 897 552 84 558 21 83 1054 86 84 29 165 84 49 275 84 369 352 84 592 450 84 851 554 84 534

83 1068 92 84 1 170 84 95 277 84 380 359 84 440 462 84 693 556 84 505

83 1075 97 84 120 174 84 34 | 281 84 321 | 366 84 806 466 84 707 558 84 526 32 83 1061 99 84 67 177 84 18 284 84 277 371 84 437 472 84 711 561 84 544 35 83 1041 101 84 111 193 84 97 287 84 286 375 84 418 474 84 853 569 84 491 38 83 1043 104 84 60 206 83 1028289 84 354 380 84 413 478 84 766 572 84 494 41 83 1063 107 84 79 215 83

1049 291
84 335 386 84 461

487 84 823 573 84 487 47 83 1025 116

84
106 222 84 372 295 84 352 391 84 947

490 84 983 576

478 32 83 1081 119

84 76 224 84 388 299 84 349 395 84 471 497 84 731 584 84 483 53 83 1066 123 84 90

227

84 300 302 84 385 398 84 514 503 84 887 585 84 609 54 83 1077 125 84 75 233 84 308 306 84 315 405 84 511 516 84 782 589 84 673 56 83 1083 127 84 108 236 84 356 312 84 323 409 84 449 518 84 793 597 84 537 62 83 1067

83 1098 240

84 276
314 84 345 413 84 403 522 84 995 601

84

562 64 83

1071
137 84 69 241 84 326 317 84 306 417 84 410 532 84 780 602 84

532 66 83

1082 139 84 114 245 84 294 320 84 366 421 84 484 535 84 776 604 84 560 68 83 1078 144 84 183 248 84 279 326 84 457 425 84 557 536 84 774 605 84 563 72 83 1088 150 84 92 251 84 347 329 84 802 427 84 454 1 539 84 728 1 609-633* 76 83 1087 156 84 37 255 84 377

*Memorandum decisions; parallel citations not required.

84

131

VOL. 87, APPELLATE DIVISION REPORTS.
Page

Page'
A. B. Farquhar Co. v. New River Mineral Attorney General of State of New York v.
Co. (84 Ñ. Y. S. 802).

329 Knickerbocker Trust Co. (Townsend v. Acritelli, People ex rel., v. Grout (84 N. Y. Oneonta, C. & R. S. R. Co., 83 N. Y. S. S. 97) 193 1117)

609 Adams v. Slingerland (84 N. Y. S. 323). 312 Ayer v. Davis (84 N. Y. S. 1117).

632 Allen v. Corn Exch. Bank (84 N. Y. S. 1001)

335 Bachmann Brewing Co. v. Wallowitz (83 Allen v. Home Bank (84 N. Y. S. 1117)... 626 N. Y. S. 1102)..

613 American Audit Co. v. Industrial Federa- Bachmann Brewing Co. v. Wallowitz (84 tion of America (84 N. Y. S. 369). 275 N. Y. S. 1117)..

614 American Publishers' Corp. v. Munro (84 Ball v. Manhattan R. Co. (84 N. Y. S. N. Y. S. 1117). 633 1118)

633 American Trust & Savings Bank v. Crown Banks' Will, Matter of (84 N. Y. S. 1118) 620 Mills (83 N. Y. S. 1102). 610 Barranco v. Law (84 N. Y. S. 421).

626 Anderson, Matter of (84 N. Y. S. 1117). 618 Barry v. Third Ave. R. Co. (84 N. Y. S. Appel v. Ætna Life Ins. Co. (86 N. Y. S. 830)

543 1128)

619 Barson v. Mulligan (84 N. Y. S. 1118). 617 Arbeely, Matter of (83 N. Y. S. 1102). 613 Bartlett's Estate, Matter of (83 N. Y. S. Arlington Co. v. Colonial Assur. Co. (84 1102)

619 N. Y. S. 1117)..

617 Barton v. Albert Palmer Co. (83 N. Y. S. Arthur v. Sire (84 N. Y. S. 1117). 633 1041)

35 Attorney General of State of New York v. Baxter, People ex rel., v. Greene (84 N. Y. Knickerbocker Trust Co. (Packer

S. 1140)

617 Oneonta, C. & R. S. R. Co., 83 N. Y. S. Beck v. Kerr (83 N. Y. S. 1057).

87 APP. DIV.-Continued.
Page

Page Dewey v. Niagara Gorge R. Co. (84 N. Y. Freeman v. Freeman (84 N. Y. S. 1126).. 621 S. 1123)

622 Frye v. Schwarz (83 N. Y. S. 1070).. 611 Diamond Soda Water Mfg. Co. v. J. N.

Hegeman & ('0. (84 N. Y. S. 1123). 631 Gallo v. Marrone (83 N. Y. S. 1106)..... 619 Dickinson, l'eople ex rel., v. Van De Carr Gebhard v. Addison (8+ N. Y, S. 418). 375 (84 N. Y. S. 461). 386 Gee v. Pendas (81 N. Y. S. 32)..

157 Diehl v. Watson (83 N. Y. S. 1104). 613 General Electric Co. v. Sire (84 N. Y. S. Ditmas v. McKane (83 N. Y. S. 1077). 54 1127)

632 Dittman v. Edison Electric Illuminating Germania Life Ins. Co. v. Sullivan (84 N. Co. (83 N. Y. S. 1078). 68 Y. S. 1127).

618 Dohse v. Batavia (84 N. Y. S. 1123). 620 Gillespie v. Yonkers R. Co. (83 N. Y. S. Donovan v. Cantor (84 N. Y. S. 1123). 632 1043)

38 Donovan v. Weed (83 N. Y. S. 1104). 612 Gimbernat v. Forgotston (84 N. Y. S. 1127) 631 Donovan, People ex rel., v. Cantor (84 N. Girvin v. Bastian (84 N. Y. S. 1127)..... 621 Y. S. 1140).

617 Girvin v. Huntington (84 N. Y. S. 1127).. 620 Doody v. Roth (83 N. Y. S. 1104).

613 Gmaehle v. Rosenberg (84 N. Y. S. 1127).. 631 Dow v. Syracuse, L. & B. Ry. (84 N. Y. S. Godfrey v. India Wharf Brewing Co. (84 1124)

620
N. Y. S. 90)...

123 Dresser v. Travis (84 N. Y. S. 1124). 632 Goetz, Matter of (84 N. Y. S. 1127).

631 Dresser v. Travis (84 N. Y. S. 1124). 633 Goldberg v. Goldstein (84 N. Y. S. 782). . 516 Dunbarton Flax Spinning, Co. 1: Green- Goldberg v. Goldstein (81 N. Y. S. 1127).. 616

wich & J. R. Co. (83 N. Y. S. 1054). 21 Goldstein v. Frishberg (83 N. Y. S. 1106) 612 Dunleavey v. Dunleavey (84 N. Y. S. 562) 601 Goldstein v. Schulman (83 N. Y. S. 1106) 612 Dunphy v. Kings County Gas & Illuminat- Gottlieb v. Alton Grain Co. (84 N. Y. S. ing Co. (83 N. Y. S. 1105). 613 413)

380 Dunscomb v. Poole (84 N. Y. S. 1124). 632 Grant v. Pratt & Lambert (84 N. Y. S. Duryea v. Duryea (84 N. Y. S. 1124)..... 633 983)

490

Gray, People ex rel., v. Board of Sup'rs of East One Hundred & Sixty-Eighth St., Livingston County (83 N. Y. S. 1114)... 618 Matter of (In re City of New York, 81 Green v. Tuchner (84 N. Y. S. 345). 314 N. Y. S. 18).

177 | Guaranty Trust Co. v. Jennings (84 N. Y. Ebbetts v. Interurban St. R. Co. (83 N. Y. S. 1128)

617 S. 1105)

613 Guaranty Trust Co. v. Jennings (84 N. Y. Edison Electric Illuminating Co., People ex S. 1128)

618 rel., v. Feitner (84 N. Y. S. 1140). 633 Guilford, Matter of (83 N. Y. S. 1117). 609 Elinsky v. Berger (84 N. Y. S. 483). 584 Gundersheimer, Matter of (84_N. Y. S. Emert v. Coffey (83 N. Y. S. 1105).

619
1128)

631 Ernest Ochs v. Pohly (81 N. Y. S. 1).. 92 Guy v. New York (84 N. Y. S. 1128). 618 Evans v. Larkin (83 N. Y. S. 1105). 612

Haight v. Stock, Grain & Provision Co. (84 Faass v. Havana Bridge Works (83 N. Y. N. Y. S. 1128)..

617 S. 1105)

619 Haight v. Stock, Grain & Provision Co. Fanger v. Caspary (84 N. Y. S. 410). 117 (84 N. Y. S. 1128).

618 Farmers' Loan & Trust Co. v. Hoffinan Hall v. Gilman (84 N. Y. S. 279).

248 House (84 N. Y. S. 1124). 632 Hall v. Gilman (84 N. Y. S. 1128).

618 Farquhar Co. v. New River Mineral Co. Hall v. Gilman (84 N. Y. S. 1128).

632 (84 N. Y. S. 802).

329 Hallenborg v. Greene (84 N. Y. S. 319). 259 Ferris, In re (83 N. Y. S. 1106).

612 Hallenborg v. Greene (84 N. Y. S. 321) 622 Fidelity & Deposit Co. of Maryland v. Ste- Hamilton v. Winch (84 N. Y. S. 1128). 631 vens (83 N. Y. S. 1106)..

609 Hanlon v. Elliott (83 N. Y. S. 1107). 613 Finn v. Prudential Life Ins. Co. (83 N. Y. Hardy, People ex rel., v. Greene (84 N. Y. S. 1106) 612 S. 673)

589 Finu, People ex rel., v. Greene (84 N. Y. Harms v. Rinaldo (84 N. Y. S. 1129). 618 S. 565)

346 Harrell v. Finck (84 N. Y. S. 1129). 617 Finnican v. Prudential Ins. Co. (83 N. Y. Hart v. Brooklyn Heights R. Co. (83 N. Y. S. 1106) 619 S. 1107)

613 Flagg v. Fisk (84 N. Y. S. 1125).

631 | Hart v. L. D. Garrett Co. (84 N. Y. S. Fleming v. Metropolitan St. R. Co. (84 N. 774)

536 Y, S. 1126).

631 Hartley v. Pioneer Iron Works (84 N. Y. Fontana v. Post Printing & Publishing Co.

S. 79)

107 (84 N. Y. S. 308).

233 | Hathaway v. Syracuse Rapid Transit R. Foster v. International Paper Co. (84 N. Y. Co. (84 N. Y. S. 1129)..

621 S. 1126)

620 Hawley v. Rochester & S. R. Co. 183 N. Fox v. Levi (84 N. Y. S. 1126). 621 Y. S. 1107)...

610 Fox v. Mahony (84 N. Y. S. 1126). 617 | Hawley v. Rochester & S. R. Co. (84 N. Y. Fox v. Rangatore (83 N. Y. S. 1106). 619 S. 1129)

621 Foy v. Barry (84 N. Y. S. 33.5). 291 Hayes v. Klock (84 N. Y. S. 363).

624 Francis H. Leggett & Co. v. Landwehr Heath y. Hasbrouck (84 X. Y. S. 1129). 618 (83 N. Y. S. 1106)..

613 Hemstreet v. Gilbert Knitting Co. (83 N. Freeman v. Brooklyn Heights R. Co. (84 Y. S. 1107)...

619 N. Y. S. 108)..... 127 | Hewit v. Booth (83 N. Y. S. 1108).

618

617

and 120 New York State Reporter
87 APP. DIV.-Continued.
Page

Past Heyward v. Willmarth (84 N. Y. S. 75).. 125 Lehmaier, People ex rel., v. Interarban St. Hidden v. Godfrey (84 N. Y. S. 1129), 632 R. Co. (84 N. Y. S. 1140). Hines v. Security Trust Co. (84 N.'Y. S. Lennan v. Hamburg American S. S. Co. 1130) 621 (84 N. Y. S. 1133).

61 H. Koehler & Co. v. Brady (84 N. Y. S. Leonard v. Donoghue (84 N. Y, S. 60) 11 457)

326 Leonard v. Donoghue (84 N. Y. S. 1133). . 614 H. Koehler & Co. v. Brady (84 N. Y. S. Levine v. Baldwin (84 N. Y. S. 92). 1130)

628 Lewis v. Pollack (84 N. Y. S. 1133). Hodge v. Hodge (83 N. Y. S. 1108). 618 Lisner v. Toplitz (84 N. Y. S. 11331. 611 Hoefer v. Grant. (80 N. Y. S. 11:39). 631 Loder v. Metropolitan St. R. Co. (83 N. Y. Hoffman v. Edison Electric Illuminating S. 1110) Co. (84 N. Y. S. 437).

371 Loftus & Co. v. Bennett (84 N. Y. S. 1150, 611 Hubbs v. Schwaneflugel (84 N. Y. S. 560) 604 Loomis v. Lake Shore & M. S. R. Co. (8 Hurley v. Metropolitan St. R. Co. (83 N. N. Y. S. 1133). Y. S. 1082)..

66 Lord, People ex rel., v. Feitner (84 N. I.

S. 1140) Ide v. Brown (83 N. Y. S. 1108).

609 Irvin, Matter of (84 N. Y. S. 707)..... 466 McAllister, United States ex rel., 5. F.

delity & Deposit Co. of Maryland (S3 N. Jackson Co. v. Haven (81 N. Y. S. 356)... 236 Y. S. 1118). Jarvis v. American Forcite Powder Mfg. McCaffrey v. Butler (84 N. Y. S. 776). Co. (84 N. Y. S. 1131)..

616 McDougall & Potter Co. v. De Hart (84 N. Jewell v, Jewell (84 N. Y. S. 1131).

631 Y. S. 1131)... J. H. Mohlinan Co. v. Landwehr (83 N. Y. McEwen v. Dimond (84 N. Y. S. 1134)..

S. 1073) John Simmons Co. v. Herter (84 N. Y. S. 83 McEwen v. Dimond (84 N. Y. S. 1137).

McGurk v. James D. Johnston Co. (St X. 1131)

Y. S. 1134). Johnson v. Keyes (84 N. Y. S. 1131). 620 Mack v. Miller (84 N. Y. S. 440). Jones, Matter of (84 N. Y. S. 1131). 620 McKesson v. Russian Co. (S+ N. Y. S. Jones v. West (84 N. Y. S. 1131).

633 1131)

McLaurin v. Cuba Co. (84 N. Y. S. 526).. 33 Kane v. Rose (84 N. Y. S. 111).

101 MeNulty y. Mt. Morris Electric Light Co. Kapella v. Nichols Chemical Co. (83 N. Y. (84 N. Y. S. 1135). S. 1109)

612 McSorley v. New York Cent. & H. R. R. Kellegher v. Forty-Second St. M. & St. N. Co. (84 N. Y. S. 1135). Ave. R. Co. (84 N. Y. S. 781).

630 Madden, People ex rel., v. Partridge (84 N. Kelly v. New York (84 N. Y. S. 349) 299 Y. S. 1140).. Kelsey v. Bank of Mansfield (81 N. Y. S. Magnolia Metal Co. v. Drew (84 N, Y. 8. 1131)

633 1135) Kenuealy v. Westchester Electric R. Co. Mauhart v. Prindle (84 N. Y. S. 1135). (83 N. Y. S. 1109)...

613 Manhattan Yacht Club v. Coleman (84 N. Kent v. Atua Ins. Co. (84 N. Y. S. 1131) 632 Y. S. 1135).... Kieley v. Barron & Cooke Heating & Pow- Mann v. Chrestopulos (84 N. Y. S. 372). er Co. (81 N. Y. S. 306)..

317 Manneschmidt v. McAvoy (83 N. Y. S. Kindorf v. Hoellerer (84 N. Y. S. 465). 628 1110) King v. Sun Printing & Publishing Co. (84 Manufacturers' & Traders' Bank v. Baner N. Y. S. 1132).

617

(People v. American Loan & Trust Com Kirsop v. Mutual Life Ins. Co. (84 N. Y. 81 N. Y. S. 114). S. 95)

170 Marchese v. Bell Telephone Co. (84 X I. Kirsop v. Mutual Life Ins. Co. (84 N. Y. S. 1135) S. 1132)

633 Marston v. New York (83 N. Y, S. 1110).. Koehler & Co. v. Brady (84 N. Y. S. 457) 326 Martin v. New Trinidad Lake Asphalt Co. Koehler & Co. v. Brady (84 N. Y. S. 1130) 628 (84 N. Y. S. 711).. Kurz v. Doerr (83 N. Y. S. 1109).

613 Marylaud Casualty Co. v. Cortland Wagoa Kurz v. Hess (83 N. Y. S. 1109).

612 Co. (84 N. Y. S. 1135).. Kushes v. Ginsberg (84 N. Y. S. 1132)... 617 Masten, People ex rel., v. Maxwell (S3 N.

Y. S. 1098). Lamb, Matter of (84 N. Y. S. 1132)... 632 Masterson v. New York (84 N. Y, S. 313 La Point v. Howland Paper Co. (83 N. Y. Mauer v. Brooklyn Heights R. Co. 184 X S. 1109)

609

Y. S. 76).. La Rocque v. Gays (83 N. Y. S. 1109). 609 Mayor, etc., of City of New York, Vatter Laroe v. Sugar Loaf Dairy Co. (81 N. Y.

of (84 N. Y. S. 18). S. (09)

585 Meehan, People ex rel., v. Simmons (83. La Rue v. Carey (83 N. Y. S. 1103). 609 Y. S. 1115). Lawlor's Will. Watter of (83 N. Y. S. 1109) 613 Meeks v. Meeks (84 N. Y. S. 67) Lawrence r. Wilson (S N. Y. S. 1109).. 612 Mertens v. Mertens (84 N. Y. S. 352). Leaux v. Vew York (S4 N. Y. S. ,31). 398 Metcalfe v. Gordon (83 N. Y. S. 1111). Leux V. New York (SIN. Y. S. J11). 405 Metcalfe v. Union Trust Co. (84 N. Y. S Lerrett & Co. v. Landwehr (83 X. Y. S. 183) 1106)

613 Metzger v. Martin (84 N. Y. S. 491).......